The Key That Fits
By Runtz4.
Laura wasn’t looking for a boyfriend when she started her first year. Head down in her books, full-ride scholarship to protect, and far too aware of the way her 5’4″ body turned heads. Voluptuous 34DD breasts, thick thighs that filled out every pair of jeans, long dark wavy hair, and soft brown eyes — even in modest clothes, she drew stares.
Henry had been different from day one. In first-year world geography, he simply sat beside her, funny and sweet, never leering. They kept ending up in the same classes, sharing notes, studying late. By the end of their third year, Laura was the one who worked up the courage.
“Henry?” she asked, heart fluttering. “Would… would you like to go someplace with me? Like Friday night?”
He smiled, running fingers through his thick brown hair. At 5’7″, he was only a little taller than her, lean from years of soccer. “Wait… like a date?”
“Yeah… is that okay?” She smiled, her hand trembling just a bit as she brushed her hair over her ear.
Since that time, they’ve been together. They shared so many interests, and they also shared one social detail… they were both virgins. Something they determined to remedy over summer break. Their first time was a bit clumsy, if not highly enthusiastic. It was fully planned and discussed in advance. She had gone on birth control years ago to help regulate her cycle, but insisted he wear a condom just to be safe.
That summer, they planned it carefully in her dorm while Janet was away. Candles, soft music, birth control already sorted. Henry was nervous, gentle, and patient, even though he clearly wanted to rip her top off and grope her huge tits.
When she finally pulled his shorts down, his smooth, hairless groin and modest cock looked perfectly fine to her inexperienced eyes. Soft it was barely more than a plump little head resting on his balls, like a shy pale grape. Hard it reached a neat four inches.
It was nothing like what she had heard from other girls; it was pleasant and easy. He never hurt her, not once. As he pushed deep inside her, bottoming out, she laughed a little to herself. That was no big deal at all.
And in just a few short strokes, he was tensing, and then shuddered as he came inside her.
Her eyes widened as he quickly slid out, planting his face between her legs and licking her to her first orgasm ever. She had heard that most girls don’t enjoy their first time, and she felt blessed to have a great memory of it. That night, they used 5 more condoms; his recovery time was nothing. She never came from his penis, but he took care of her every time with his mouth.
It was sweet. It was theirs.
Then Janet started dating Steve.
Janet was 5’8″ of pale, freckled chaos with wild red curly hair and a tight 32B body that lived in tiny tops, and Lauara was convinced she had never even owned a bra—a free-spirited nympho who made everything sexual. Steve — 6’3″, blond scruffy face, blue eyes, model looks, and a permanent rich-boy smirk — played striker on the same soccer team as Henry. He had a thick Cockney edge to his voice that got rougher when he was taking the piss out of people.
From the first locker-room sighting, the nickname stuck.
“Oi, Little Hank!” Steve would shout every time he saw him.
Laura thought it was about height. Until the night Steve and Janet were making out heavily on one bed while she and Henry tried to watch a film on the other.
“Steve, noooo!” Janet laughed, pushing him back. Her perky tits strained against her thin t-shirt.
“Come on, babe,” Steve grinned, his feet hanging off the end of the bed. “I ain’t shy, no need, got nothin’ to be embarrassed ‘bout. Not like Little Hank over there, yeah.”
“Stop calling him that!” Laura snapped. “He’s not even that short.”
Steve barked a laugh. “Short? Nah, love, it’s ‘cause of his tiny button dick!”
“Steve, please…” Henry muttered.
Laura jumped in to defend him. “He’s only small when he’s soft. When he’s hard, it sticks out a little past my fist.” She held up her small hand to show them.
Janet and Steve lost it, howling with laughter.
“You should see it soft!” Steve crowed, talking to Janet. “Like a little pale grape sittin’ a top of his hairless balls, innit? Smallest on the whole fuckin’ team.”
He stood up, yanked his shorts down, and gripped his heavy cock. Laura’s eyes went wide. Even completely soft, it was thick and long — easily six inches of meaty man flesh swinging in his big hand. He spun it around like a helicopter.
“I ain’t even ‘ard yet, me thick bird!” he laughed. “When you’re ready for a real man, thick bird, just say the word. Fuck them enormous top bollocks proper, I will.”
That was the first time Laura saw Steve’s cock. It wasn’t the last. He was never shy about “accidentally” exposing himself.
She’d come back to the dorm early from the library and opened the door without knocking. Janet was on all fours on her bed, face buried in a pillow, moaning like a whore. Steve was behind her, gripping her hips and slamming into her with long, brutal strokes. His thick cock looked obscene — easily twice as thick as Henry’s and much longer, veins bulging, shiny with Janet’s cream.
Laura had frozen in the doorway. For several long seconds, her eyes locked onto that massive, pistoning shaft stretching her roommate’s pussy wide open. The wet, filthy schlick-schlick-schlick sound filled the room. Steve had glanced over, caught her staring, and just smirked as he kept fucking Janet even harder.
She’d backed out and closed the door, heart hammering… but the image had burned itself into her brain.
Then there was the afternoon in the dorm when she walked in, and Steve was sitting on the edge of Janet’s bed in a pair of loose basketball shorts, legs spread. His heavy cock had slipped out the wide leg hole, hanging thick and soft against his thigh — at least six inches of meat, even completely limp. He didn’t bother covering it. He just looked up at her with that cocky grin.
“Alright, thick bird?”
Laura had muttered something and looked away, but her eyes kept flicking back to it. She hated how heavy and full it looked. How different it was from Henry’s tiny little nub.
The worst — or best — was the night she was already in bed, lights off, trying to sleep. Janet and Steve thought she was out cold. She heard the familiar wet sucking sounds and couldn’t help herself. She cracked one eye open just enough to see.
Janet was on her knees between Steve’s legs, greedily sucking his huge cock. Even in the dim light from the streetlamp outside, Laura could see everything — Janet’s lips stretched obscenely wide around the thick shaft, saliva dripping down onto his heavy balls as she bobbed and gagged. Steve’s hand was in her red hair, guiding her deeper.
“That’s it, love… choke on that fat dick,” he groaned in his dirty accent.
Laura’s hand had slid into her panties almost on its own. She found her clit soaked and swollen. She rubbed herself in slow, guilty circles while she watched her roommate worship that massive cock. When Steve finally growled and started pumping cum down Janet’s throat, Laura came too — a quiet, shaking orgasm that left her biting her lip so hard she nearly drew blood.
She came again later that week, replaying the image of Steve with Henry’s tongue buried deep inside her.
She told herself it was just curiosity. Nothing more.
But deep down, she knew she was lying.
Janet only poured fuel on the fire, casually complaining how sore she was after Steve fucked her senseless, how many times she came on his big dick, and how teasing her about how Henry’s fully hard penis was still smaller than Steve’s soft cock.
So when Janet begged them to come on this holiday — “Steve’s dad has a little place on the islands, it’s our last proper break before graduation, you deserve it” — Laura had reluctantly said yes. It was a chance for her and Henry to have a special time together. And, one last trip before graduation.
The private villa on Virgin Gorda was stunning — a sprawling Spanish-style estate with whitewashed walls, red-tiled roofs, and sweeping views of turquoise water. But Steve didn’t lead them toward the main house.
“Pops said we could use the cabana,” he announced with a smirk, guiding them around the side to a much smaller guest hut tucked near the beach. “Stay out of the big house, though, yeah? His rules.”
Laura and Henry stepped inside and immediately exchanged a glance. It was tiny. One bedroom, a single toilet, and an outdoor shower with almost zero privacy — just a bamboo screen that barely reached chest height.
“Oh, it’s perfect!” Janet squealed, bouncing on her toes. Her red curls bounced as she threw her arms around Steve’s neck. “We’re going to have so much fun!”
Laura looked around with indifference; the motion-sickness pill she had taken earlier left her nicely drowsy, detached, and a bit more affectionate toward Henry than she would normally have displayed.
“Oi, Little Hank!” Steve called, his thick Cockney accent cutting through the warm air. “You and your thick bird take the couch — it folds out, innit?”
He grinned, then scooped Janet up like she weighed nothing, his big hands sliding straight under her shirt to grope her perky tits. A few strides later, he tossed her onto the bed and kicked the bedroom door shut behind them.
It might as well have been wide open.
Within seconds, the sounds started.
“God, baby…It’s so big already,” Janet moaned, her voice breathy and eager. The wet, sloppy sounds of her sucking his thick cock filled the small cabana — loud, greedy slurps, gagging noises, and the occasional pop as she pulled off to catch her breath. “Mmmph— fuck, I love this fat dick…”
Steve’s low groan rumbled through the wall. “That’s it, love. Get it nice and wet for me.”
Then the real fucking began.
The rhythmic slap of skin on skin. Janet’s desperate, broken cries. “It’s too big— oh fuck, Steve, you’re stretching me so good! You’re gonna ruin my pussy forever— yes, right there!”
Laura’s cheeks burned. She tried to focus on unfolding the couch, but her nipples had already tightened against her top, and a slick heat was building between her thighs. Henry stood beside her, breathing heavier, the front of his shorts already tented by his modest erection.
They shared one heated look. That was all it took.
Laura peeled her top off, letting her heavy 34DD breasts spill free. She shoved her shorts down, kicked them aside, then pushed Henry onto the pull-out couch. Without a word, she straddled him, pulled his shorts down just enough, as he fumbled with his condom, sliding it down his shorts. Slipped her soaked panties to the side. His little 4-inch pickle— already rock-hard — slid easily into her dripping cunt.
“Fuck…” Henry whispered, hands instantly grabbing her tits.
Three minutes. That was all he lasted. He thrust up into her tight, velvety heat, sucking greedily on her nipples while she ground down on him. With a choked groan, he buried his face between her breasts and came hard, pumping a warm tablespoon of thick cum into the condom.
He stayed hard — he always did — still buried inside her as she kept rolling her hips. Laura reached for her bag, pulled out her small purple wand vibrator, and flicked it on. The low hum seemed deafening in the tiny cabana.
Henry’s eyes widened in panic. “Babe— they’ll hear…”
She didn’t care. She pressed the buzzing head firmly against her swollen clit and kept grinding on his little mushroom-shaped dick. The wet sounds were obscene — loud, squelching, like an electric toothbrush submerged in warm cream. Her juices coated his stomach and balls, flinging in tiny droplets with every frantic circle of her hips.
Steve and Janet were getting louder next door. Janet’s voice cracked into a rising wail: “I’m cumming— oh my god, I’m cumming on your huge cock—!”
That pushed Laura over the edge.
Her orgasm hit like a wave. Her pussy clenched hard around Henry’s modest length, and she squirted for the very first time — a hot, messy gush that soaked his stomach and the couch beneath them. Her hips bucked so violently that he slipped out, his small cock slapping wetly against her ass. Before he could push back in, he came again, filling the condom with a second, weaker spurt while groaning into her tits.
Janet’s muffled giggle drifted through the wall. “Sounds like everyone’s having fun…”
The cabana fell quiet except for heavy breathing and the distant crash of waves. Laura collapsed onto Henry’s chest, flushed and trembling, her soaked pussy still twitching around his spent little cock. She kissed him softly, but her mind kept drifting to the filthy, loud way Janet had screamed for Steve’s much bigger dick. With the soft, gentle kisses, lazily stroking his hair, while Henry drew patterns on her back with his fingertips, and the effects of the pill, she drifted off, lying on top of him.
Then the bedroom door swung open.
“Fuckin’ hell,” Steve chuckled, his heavy 9-inch cock still half-hard and swinging. “Look atchya, thick bird!” He laughed, looking down at them still embraced on the pullout bed.
Before Laura could react, Steve snatched Henry’s shorts and underwear in one smooth motion, tossing them across the room.
Laura’s eyes snapped open. She had dozed off on top of Henry, still topless, her heavy 34DD tits pressed against his chest. Henry stirred beneath her, groggy and confused.
“Oh, God!” Laura gasped. She sat up quickly, trying to cover her breasts with her arms, but the sudden movement pushed her hips higher on Henry’s stomach. That left his soft little penis completely exposed — just a tiny, spent acorn head resting on his smooth balls, glistening with her juices, the used condom had fallen off and lay between his legs.
“Shit!” Janet burst out laughing, plopping down on the bed, still flushed and naked. “You weren’t kidding, Steve. It really is just a little nub!” She leaned in closer and casually pinched Henry’s dick between her thumb and finger, feeling his little nub.
Henry twitched hard. A fresh wave of burning humiliation rolled through him… and his baby carrot betrayed him instantly, twitching and swelling to its full modest 4 inches in Janet’s hand.
Janet giggled again. “Aww, poor thing! Look at that — it liked being laughed at.” She reached over and picked up Laura’s purple wand vibrator from the couch, waving it like a trophy. “No wonder you need this little toy, Hank. Steve’s cock would probably split poor Laura in half.”
“Oi, lookie here!” Steve picked up the used condom and spun it around. “Never seen one this small. And look at that little bit of cum – like a thimble full.”
Janet saw the condom package and read it – “Caliber, size small!” She burst out laughing. “Oh my God, you have to get special condoms for his tiny tot.”
Laura’s face burned crimson. She scrambled for her top while Henry lay there frozen, mortified but helplessly hard. Steve just smirked, slowly stroking his thick, soft cock in front of everyone.
“Welcome to paradise, Little Hank.”
*****
A few hours later, after everyone had cooled down (and Steve had made plenty more crude jokes), the group got ready to head out.
Laura changed in the tiny bathroom, squeezing into the ridiculously skimpy red bikini Janet had talked her into buying. She stared at herself in the mirror on the back of the door and felt her stomach flip.
“What am I doing?” she huffed, turning to look at her thick ass. The bottoms barely covered anything — the thin red fabric disappeared between her full cheeks, and the top was so tight her heavy 34DD breasts were spilling out the sides. Every movement made her tits jiggle dangerously.
“Fuck it,” she muttered and stepped out.
The reaction was instant.
“Fuck me,” Steve whistled, eyes raking over her body. “Now that’s what I’m talkin’ about, Laura!”
Henry’s mouth fell open, equal parts turned on and jealous. He loved seeing Laura like this… but hated that Steve got to see it too.
Janet was already strutting around in an even more revealing thin string bikini. Two tiny triangles barely contained her smaller, perky tits, and the bottoms were little more than a ribbon that clung so tightly to her pussy you could clearly see the outline of her clit. She grinned and did a little spin.
“See? I told you you’d look insane in red,” Janet said, slapping Laura’s ass playfully. “Let’s go have some proper fun.”
Henry, still a little red-faced but eager to move on, pulled out his phone on the deck. “So… I’ve been researching the island. There’s an old legend about a hidden sea cave that pirates used in the 1700s to stash treasure and prisoners. I think I’ve pinned down the entrance. We could take jet skis this afternoon.”
Steve raised an eyebrow. “Sounds dodgy, but I’m in.”
Janet clapped. “Yes! Adventure time.”
Laura nodded, heart racing from both nerves and the way Steve kept staring at her barely-covered body. “Let’s do it.”
They pulled out two powerful jet skis and raced along the coast. After thrilling bounces through waves and a few heart-stopping near-misses past jagged rocks, they spotted the hidden marking Henry had described. Carefully, they slipped through the narrow crack in the cliff.
Inside, the water calmed instantly. They beached the jet skis on a smooth sand shelf deep in the cave and clicked on their flashlights.
The air was cool and damp. They explored until the beams lit up an old iron-barred cell carved into the rock — half prison, half treasure vault. The heavy gate stood slightly ajar, ancient key still in the lock.
Steve’s eyes sparkled. While the others stepped inside, he quietly palmed the key and slipped it into his swim trunks.
Then he swung the heavy gate shut.
CLANG.
Laura jumped.
“Steve!” Janet laughed. “You absolute dickhead.”
“What the hell?” Laura spun around. “Open it!”
Henry stepped forward. “Give me the key, man. This isn’t funny.”
Steve leaned against the bars, arms crossed, arrogant grin in place. His eyes dropped shamelessly to Laura’s overflowing red bikini top.
“I might ‘ave the key somewhere on me…” he drawled. “But Laura’s gonna have to search for it. Thoroughly, yeah?”
Steve leaned against the bars, arms crossed, that arrogant grin firmly in place. His eyes dropped shamelessly to Laura’s overflowing red bikini top.
Janet rolled her eyes. “Steve, come on. Stop being a prick. Just open the gate.”
“Nah, this is proper fun,” Steve laughed. “Laura’s got the best hands for the job. What d’ya say, thick bird?”
Laura’s cheeks burned. “This isn’t funny, Steve.”
Henry stepped forward, jaw clenched. “Give me the fucking key, man. Now.”
Steve just smirked wider and spread his arms. “Make me, Little Hank.” The two scuffled a bit, but Steve is much bigger and tossed him aside.
Laura, just wanting this to end, stepped up to him and started patting down the outside of his swim trunks.
“Won’t find it there.” He smuldered, thrusting his hips. The massive, heavy outline of his soft cock made her hand pause, then she slid it inside the front of his swimsuit.
“I can’t find it,” she huffed after a moment, cheeks flaming. “There’s… there’s too much stuff down here.”
Steve and Janet both laughed.
“Yeah, I bet,” Steve grinned. “Go on then. Proper search.”
Laura hooked her fingers into his waistband and tugged his trunks down. His thick, heavy cock flopped out — so much bigger than Henry’s, even completely soft. She wrapped her soft hand around it, lifted the thick shaft upward, and cupped his smooth balls. There it was — the ancient key, easily 3 inches long, tucked snugly between his cock and sack.
Laura pulled it free, holding it up between two fingers while still gripping his warm, heavy dick in her other hand.
Steve’s eyes flashed with triumph. He snatched the key from her fingers in one quick motion and held it high above his head, well out of reach.
“Nice try, love. But we’re just gettin’ started—”
Henry’s fist flew.
CRACK.
The punch landed clean on Steve’s jaw. Steve’s head snapped back violently, and he dropped like a stone. Janet dove, catching her boyfriend, but hitting the cave floor hard and hurting her arm. The key flew from his hand, skittered across the stone, and dropped straight down a hole in the center of the cell — visible but completely unreachable.
For a second, everything went silent.
“Oh, my God!” Janet screamed. She held Steve, cradling his head in her lap. Tears were already streaming down her face. “Steve! Steve, wake up! Henry, what the fuck did you do?! You killed him!”
Henry stood frozen, fist still clenched, horror washing over his face. “I… I didn’t mean to hit him that hard. Shit. Is he breathing? Janet, is he breathing?!”
Laura watched, eyes wide with shock; she had never seen Henry act so decisively and animalistic. She should have been appalled by such a toxic masculine outburst, but she felt a warmth between her legs.
Steve groaned weakly. His eyes fluttered open. He blinked groggily up at Janet, clearly dazed.
“…Where the fuck are we?” he mumbled, voice thick and confused.
Janet held her arm close to her body, pain radiating, and let out a relieved sob and hugged his head tighter to her chest. “We’re trapped in the cell, baby. When Henry punched you, the key fell. It’s down there.” She pointed to the narrow hole in the stone floor. The ancient key glinted just out of reach in the flashlight beam.
Steve rubbed his jaw with a wince, slowly sitting up. “Fuckin’ hell, Little Hank… you proper decked me.”
They all took turns trying to reach the key. The hole was a maddeningly perfect cylinder — about two inches wide and eight inches deep — and likely held a post of some kind.
“God, I can almost get it,” Laura strained, kneeling and pushing her hand in as far as it would go. “It’s really just my thumb getting in the way…” She huffed in frustration and sat back. “If we only had something sticky — gum, sap, maybe even mud?”
Steve, still lying on the floor with his head in Janet’s lap, let out a weak but wicked chuckle.
“Funny you should say that, thick bird. Janet, remember that time I shot all over your face and shirt back at my place? You took your top off and threw it on my desk. A few hours later, I picked it up… and my dorm key was stuck to it like glue.”
Janet’s eyes lit up through her pained tears. “Oh my god, that could actually work.”
Steve continued, voice still a bit shaky. “We fill one of Laura’s bikini cups with a proper load, shove it down the hole with the strap hanging out, let it set, and fish the key right out.”
Henry’s face burned. Laura looked mortified.
“But Hanky-Panky’s little dribble ain’t gonna cut it,” Steve said, remembering the small load in the condom they’d all seen earlier. “We’re gonna need a real load. And since your punchy boyfriend is the reason we’re in this mess…”
Laura narrowed her eyes. “Why my top? Janet can do it.” Then she looked at Janet’s humble breasts, and tiny top, and then down to her own. “Never mind, dumb question.” She chuckled nervously.
Steve looked up at her with a slow, hungry smirk, his thick, soft cock already starting to twitch against his thigh.
“You’ll have to do, Honey. My arm is killing me.” Janet said.
“Why do I have to do anything?”
‘Cause I’ll cum faster for you, thick bird. A stranger’s hands, and all that. And those massive great Charlies, I’ve been dreaming about for two years… it has to be you. You’re the one who’s gonna get me there quick.”
Janet stroked Steve’s hair gently and nodded, a wicked little smile forming. “He’s right, babe. He’s got that retarded ejaculation thing — takes him forever.”
“Then… just wank off on your own.” She cussed
“No can do, bird. That wasn’t working since I was wee lad, and Mr. Johnson got his first taste of tart.” He smiled.
“It’s true – the poor boy can’t wank proper.” Janet shared, “But, something new and filthy turns him on faster. And those massive tits of yours? He’s been thinking about them since the first time he saw you.”
Laura stood there breathing fast, caught between fury and an undeniable rush of heat between her thighs. Henry looked like he wanted the cave to swallow him whole.
“Fine,” she said quietly, voice tight. “But this is it. We get the key, and we’re done.” Laura swallowed hard, then reached behind her back and untied the skimpy red bikini top. The large cups fell away, letting her heavy 34DD breasts spill free into the cool cave air. Her nipples stiffened instantly. Henry looked torn between protective rage and helpless arousal. Steve let out a low whistle.
“Fuckin’ hell…”
Laura moved between Steve’s spread legs, her heart hammering so hard she could feel it in her throat. Janet’s injured arm rested uselessly against her chest while she continued stroking Steve’s messy blond hair with her good hand, whispering soft encouragement.
Laura hooked her fingers into the waistband of his swim trunks and slowly pulled them down. His heavy, soft cock flopped out and landed with a thick thwack against his thigh.
Oh my fucking God…
*****
Steve’s cock was even bigger up close. The sheer weight of it stunned her. She hesitated for a second, then wrapped both hands around the warm, veiny shaft. Her fingers didn’t even come close to meeting. It felt impossibly heavy, thick, and alive in her palms — like hot, smooth velvet wrapped around solid meat. She could feel the thick ridge of the head, the pulsing heat, and the surprising heft of it even while completely soft.
This is what a real cock feels like… she thought, a rush of guilty heat flooding between her legs. Henry’s entire hard dick is thinner than this soft monster…
Janet’s voice was low and coaxing. “Go on, Laura… use both hands. He’s so thick. Really work the whole shaft.”
Laura swallowed hard and started stroking him slowly, marveling at how much of his cock still stuck out beyond her fists. Without thinking, the humiliating comparison slipped out of her mouth in a breathless whisper:
“Jesus… It’s so much heavier than Henry’s little thing…”
Steve let out a low, amused chuckle. Janet grinned.
“That’s it, babe,” Janet purred.
Steve groaned low as Laura started stroking him with long, slow pumps. Several minutes passed. Her arms began to burn. Henry had never lasted anywhere near this long.
“You’ll have to do more than that, love,” Steve murmured, voice rough with need.
Janet coached her, “Lean forward, babe. Press those big tits around his cock and stroke. That’s what’s going to make him explode for you.”
Laura’s face burned with shame, but she didn’t stop. She leaned forward, pressing her heavy, bare 34DD breasts around the thick shaft while her hands kept pumping the head. The feeling of his warm, heavy cock nestled between her tits made her pussy throb.
“Suck his cock,” Janet pressed, “See how it sticks up even past your large breasts, I bet Henry’s doesn’t do that, does it?”
“No… no it doesn’t.”
What the fuck is she saying? Henry watched in humiliated silence, his own little 4-inch dick straining pathetically in his trunks.
Janet noticed immediately and laughed softly. “Aww, look at Little Hank. Already hard again just watching his girlfriend play with a real cock.” She called him over and flicked the tiny bulge in his shorts. “That little mushroom could never fill a bikini cup. Steve’s gonna drown it.”
Henry could only watch, burning with shame and unbearable arousal.
Laura pressed her heavy tits around his thick shaft and took the fat head into her mouth.
Oh my God…
She had never been able to do this with Henry. His little 4-inch nub was far too small to titfuck and suck at the same time. But Steve’s cock… his head was so thick it forced her jaw wide open. Her lips stretched obscenely around the fat, spongy crown as she sucked greedily, swirling her tongue over the head while her soft breasts squeezed and slid up and down the veiny shaft.
“Mmmph—” she moaned around his cock, the vibration making Steve groan.
“Fuuuuck, thick bird,” Steve hissed, his voice rough. “That’s it… get that pretty mouth on me.”
Laura’s cheeks burned with humiliation, but she couldn’t stop. She bobbed her head, sucking harder, taking as much of his fat head as she could while pumping the rest of his massive length between her tits. Saliva ran down his shaft, making everything slick and filthy.
Henry could never fill my mouth like this… never stretch my jaw… never fuck my tits like this…
The thought made her whimper around his cock. She was soaking wet, her tiny red g-string ruined.
Janet watched with a wicked smile, still stroking Steve’s hair. “Look at her go. She’s loving that big dick, isn’t she? Poor Little Hank could never give her this.”
Laura didn’t answer. She just kept sucking and titfucking him with desperate, hungry strokes — lost in the overwhelming size and heat of Steve’s cock.
Finally, Steve’s hips bucked.
“Fuuuuck— here it comes, thick bird—!” Laura grabbed her top, pointing Steve’s large cock at the cup.
He erupted like a broken fire hydrant. Massive, heavy ropes of thick cum blasted into the cup of Laura’s red bikini top, filling it fast and overflowing. The load was so huge and creamy it looked like someone had dumped a whole jar of warm mayonnaise into the fabric.
“Jesus fucking Christ…” Henry whispered, staring.
Laura carefully lifted the cum-brimming cup. “How the hell am I supposed to get this down there and mash it against the key?”
“We’ll need more fabric to pack the hole,” Janet said.
Laura snatched Steve’s swim trunks, balled them up, and rammed them into the cylindrical hole, using the cum-soaked bikini cup as the sticky end. It went most of the way.
“Almost…” She looked at Henry with a pouty, apologetic face. “Sorry, babe.”
Henry sighed, but slipped his shorts off. His little 4-inch hard-on sprang free, already leaking like a faucet.
Steve laughed. “Look at that pathetic little button. Couldn’t even hide a fucking Tic Tac under that sad excuse for a dick.”
Janet grinned. “Aww, it’s so cute when it tries. Just a tiny baby carrot on top of his smooth little balls.”
Even Laura smirked. “Be nice… my eager little nub is helping us out.”
They packed Henry’s shorts on top and settled in to wait.
“How long?” Laura asked.
“‘Bout an hour for that cum to set like glue,” Steve muttered.
The next hour was pure filthy teasing.
Steve and Henry were naked. Laura wore only her tiny red bottoms. Janet, feeling like the odd one out, eventually peeled off her top too, her perky tits on full display.
Janet started in:
“I’ve never seen a dick that fucking small. Laura, be honest — do you even feel that little worm when it’s inside you?”
Laura’s voice started shy but quickly got nastier.
“Of course I feel it… most of the time.”
Janet pushed harder. “I don’t think I could ever go back to a normal dick again. Steve’s fat cock has completely ruined my cunt. And Henry’s not even average.”
Laura, breathing heavier: “Henry’s tiny little nub may not look like much… but he’s so fucking eager to please with his tongue and fingers.”
Janet grinned wickedly. “Don’t you ever just want a real cock? Something that actually fills you up and wrecks you?”
Laura’s answers grew bolder:
“His tiny one is perfect for me… usually.”
Then later: “Henry’s baby dick might be tiny, but he makes me cum with his mouth every single time.”
Henry sat there leaking pre-cum, humiliated and rock-hard.
After nearly an hour, they pulled the soaked bundle out. Laura gently tugged her bikini top free.
“I can feel it — it’s coming …”
Steve smirked. “First time you’ve ever heard her say that, huh, Little Hank?”
The key was almost there… then it slipped and fell back down with a clink.
“Fuck. We have to do it again,” Laura groaned.
“That’s gonna be hard, thick bird. It takes a while to get this back to life.”
Laura looked at his soft, spent cock. “Really? Henry can go four or five times easily.” She smirked.
Steve hissed, “I said it’d be hard, love… not impossible. But you’re not gonna like what it takes this time.”
Before Henry could react, Steve was standing between the two girls, as Laura and Janet attacked his cock with their mouths, tongues, and hands. They got him rock-hard again, but he was still nowhere near cumming.
Janet got desperate. She dropped to all fours, ass up, untied her bottoms, and spread her pussy. “Fuck me stupid, baby. Wreck this cunt.”
Steve pounded her like an animal. Janet screamed through two shattering orgasms before she collapsed, his thick cock popping out with a wet schlorp. Her pussy gaped wide open, red, swollen, and drooling cum. “I can’t… I can’t take any more of that monster,” she sobbed, and held her arm in pain.
Steve turned to Laura, cock throbbing. “Your turn, thick bird. Get on your back and spread that pretty pussy.”
Laura looked at Henry. His tiny dick was twitching and leaking.
“It’s okay, babe,” Henry rasped.
Laura lay back, legs wide. Steve knelt between them, laid his massive cock on her stomach so she could see exactly how deep he was going to go, then rubbed the fat head against her tight opening.
“I’ll try to go slow, love.”
Janet pulled Henry against her, wrapped her legs around him, and grabbed his little dick in one hand. “So fucking tiny it fits in my palm like a little toy,” she whispered and grabbed Laura’s cum crusted top.
Steve pushed in.
“Oh my fucking GOD!” Laura’s eyes rolled back. “It’s so thick— you’re splitting me open!”
Even just the head and first few inches stretched her more than Henry ever had. She came violently within a minute, shaking and staring straight at Henry:
“Oh baby, I’m sorry— I’m cumming so fucking hard on his cock!”
Janet felt him tensing and held the fresh cup to his dick. Henry spurted instantly into the bikini cup Janet held.
Steve kept feeding her, inch by inch. Laura came again. And again. Every thrust made her scream filthier than she ever had.
“Fuck— he’s so deep! I can feel him in my stomach!”
Janet milked Henry through orgasm after orgasm, laughing. “Look at this pathetic little tater tot shooting again and again while his girlfriend gets properly fucked. But, damn, does it ever go soft?”
By the time Janet and Henry had coated the inside of the large top, Laura had cum four times and was a shaking, drooling mess.
Laura pushed Steve off. “I have an idea.”
She slid the cum-soaked bikini cup over the head of Steve’s cock (cum side out) and told him to ram it down the hole and hold it there with pressure.
Steve shoved his cock into the tight stone cylinder. “Oi, it’s tight! I feel the fucking key…”
Laura lay in front of him so he could grope, slap, and suck her tits. Janet reached between his legs and squeezed his balls.
Forty-five brutal minutes passed. Steve’s cock was raw and sore.
“I can’t keep it up— I have to pull out!”
He slowly withdrew. The rough stone scraped the entire length of his shaft. When he finally popped free, his cock was shredded — covered in cuts, scrapes, and raw abrasions.
“Oh my fucking GOD!” Steve howled, clutching his mangled dick.
They waited fifteen more minutes, then Laura slowly pulled her bikini top off.
The key came up glued tight in the dried cum.
They escaped just before dark. The local doctor patched Steve up, wrapping his cock in gauze, and gave him a shot that would prevent him from getting an erection for the next couple of days and ordered no sex for three weeks.
That night in the dark cabana, Laura curled against Henry.
“Are you okay, baby?” she whispered.
“Yeah… that was fucking insane. But watching you take his cock…”
“I know. I’m so sorry. I tried not to cum on him… but his dick felt too good.”
“No… I … fuck, please don’t think I am weird. But, it was really hot.” He confessed,” I really liked being teased too…but, do you still want me?”
“Oh my God, yes.” She kissed him hard. “His huge cock stretched me out and made me cum like crazy… but I choose you. Every single time.”
She straddled him and sank her swollen, well-fucked pussy down onto his little 4-inch dick.
“Oh fuuuuck,” she moaned in pure relief. “Your tiny little nub feels so fucking good in my wrecked cunt, baby. So perfect and snug after that monster stretched me out.”
She rode him hard, moaning the whole time filthily:
“I love your baby dick… your cute little tater tot… your tiny pink worm… God, I love it so much!”
They came together screaming.
For the rest of the week, Laura and Henry fucked constantly — right in front of Steve, who could only watch with his bandaged, aching cock. Janet borrowed Laura’s purple toy and vibed herself senseless watching them, then finally begged:
Janet’s voice came out desperate and whiny.
“Please, Laura… I’m fucking dying here. Let your little-dick boyfriend fuck me. Just once. I need to feel that tiny thing inside me.”
Laura slowed her hips, still impaled on Henry’s modest 4 inches, and looked over with a wicked little smile.
“You really want my boyfriend’s little guy?” she asked, deliberately clenching around him.
Janet nodded frantically. “Yes… please.”
Laura lifted herself off Henry with a wet pop. His little dick slapped wetly against his stomach, shiny with her juices, barely more than a swollen pink finger.
“Go on, baby,” Laura said sweetly, patting Henry’s thigh. “Give Janet what she’s begging for.”
Henry didn’t need telling twice. He moved between Janet’s slim, pale legs, lined up his minuscule muscle, and pushed inside her soaked pussy.
“Oh my God…” Janet burst out laughing even as she moaned. “It’s so fucking small! I can barely feel it… It’s like a little finger poking around in there!”
Henry’s face burned bright red, but he started thrusting anyway, his smooth groin slapping against her.
Janet reached down between them and pressed her pussy tighter around him.
“Look at this cute little biscuit,” she cooed mockingly. “It’s so tiny. But… oh my God, it feels good to have something inside me.” She slid the vibrator to her clit, and let it stimulate her while Henry fucked her loose cunt.
Janet’s teasing grew filthier as Henry’s pace increased.
“Mmm, I can hardly feel you, baby. Are you even all the way in? Fuck, it’s like a little warm worm wriggling around in my pussy… so cute and useless.” She squeezed his tiny shaft tighter. “This is the smallest dick that’s ever been inside me. I love it. I fucking love how pathetic it is.”
Laura watched intently, fingering herself. “Tell him how much you love his little nub, Janet.”
“I do,” Janet panted, eyes rolling back. “I love this tiny little grape dick. It’s so fucking adorable. Most guys stretch me out… but your boyfriend’s pathetic prick just tickles my clit from the inside. Keep going, Little Hank — fuck me with that sad little button mushroom!”
Henry was groaning, humiliated, and insanely turned on. He pounded her faster, his smooth groin smacking wetly against her.
Janet suddenly arched hard, her voice cracking into a scream.
“Oh my fucking GOD — I’m cumming! I’m cumming on your tiny baby dick!”
Her pussy clenched and fluttered around his little cock as she squirted hard, soaking his balls and the sheets. She kept jerking his tiny shaft frantically the entire time, milking him through her orgasm.
“Don’t stop — keep fucking me with that pathetic little prick! Yesyesyes—!”
Henry couldn’t hold back. With a humiliated whimper, he buried himself as deep as his 4 inches would go and unloaded inside her, pumping his load into Janet’s spasming cunt while she laughed and moaned through the aftershocks.
When he finally pulled out, Janet looked down between her legs and giggled breathlessly.
“Aw, you barely made a mess… just a cute little dribble. God, I love your tiny dick.”
Laura crawled over, kissed Henry deeply, and whispered proudly against his lips, “That’s my good little boy,” she whispered, stroking his hair. “The cave key caused us so much trouble… but your tiny key? It slides right in and unlocks me every single time.”
The End.
*The opinions/views expressed in this story (and in any comments) are those of the author and do not represent this site. We support freedom of speech. This story has been previously published on other free websites (Reddit, Literotica) and is now in the public domain, allowing us to republish it here.