Not Tonight
A Fictional Story by EgonOlsen1925.
That fact sat on me like a stone. It sat on me in the way that facts about your body sit on you—heavy, immovable, the kind of thing you carry around and try not to think about but that presses into you at every quiet moment. In the shower. In bed at night. In the locker room. On dates, especially on dates, when the conversation is going well, and the laughter is easy, and you can feel the trajectory of the evening curving toward the thing you haven’t done yet and aren’t sure you can do.
I’d had chances before. Or near-chances—moments that could have become something if I’d pushed, if I’d been braver, if I hadn’t found a way to end the evening early or redirect the conversation or simply not follow up on the text. I’d had girlfriends—short-term, casual, the kind of relationships that stayed mostly above the waist. I’d done things: hands, mouths, the outer regions of sex. But I’d never put my dick inside a woman. I’d never had that specific, that central, that defining experience, and the longer I went without it, the more impossible it seemed—not just logistically, but psychologically. The weight of it grew. The virginity became a thing, an object, a barrier that I was increasingly afraid to approach because approaching it meant revealing the thing I was most afraid to reveal.
My dick is small. I’ve known this since I was fourteen, since the first time I saw another boy’s erection in the locker room and understood, with a sudden, sick clarity, that mine was not the same. Three inches hard. Less than an inch soft. Thin. The kind of thin that makes a condom look loose, the kind of small that makes you understand, in a visceral, bodily way, why the word “little” exists. I’d spent years managing this knowledge—wearing the right underwear, avoiding the wrong situations, keeping the physical reality of my body at a distance from the social reality of my life. I’d gotten good at it. Good at oral, good with my hands, good at the things that didn’t require my dick to be present or accounted for. Good at being a sexual person without actually using my penis, because using my penis meant showing my penis, and showing my penis meant being seen, and being seen meant being known.
—
Her name doesn’t matter. What matters is that she was young—my age, maybe a year younger—and pretty in the way that made me nervous—dark hair, sharp eyes, a laugh that was loud and unselfconscious. We’d met through mutual friends, texted for a couple of weeks, and gone on two dates that had gone well. Dinner, drinks, the kind of dates where the conversation flows and the silences are comfortable, and you can feel the attraction building in the space between you. She was into me. I could tell. The way she leaned in when I talked, the way she touched my arm, the way she looked at me—there was want in it. She wanted me. And I wanted her, and the wanting was tangled up with the fear, because wanting her meant eventually having to show her, and showing her meant eventually having to be seen.
The third date ended at her apartment.
She lived in a one-bedroom in a neighborhood I didn’t know well—a fourth-floor walk-up with narrow stairs, a door that stuck, and a bed that took up most of the room. She put on music. She offered me a drink. I sat on her couch and held the glass and felt the nervousness in my stomach—not the normal nervousness of a man about to have sex for the first time, but the specific, pointed, extra nervousness of a man about to have sex for the first time with a small dick.
We made out on the couch first. She was a good kisser—aggressive, confident, the kind of kisser who takes the lead and lets you follow. Her hands were in my hair, on my neck, on my chest. My hands were on her waist, her hips, the small of her back. I could feel her body under her clothes—warm, soft, the curves of her pressing against me—and I could feel my own body responding, my dick stirring in my jeans, the small, familiar stirring that I knew would not amount to much.
I moved first. I always move first with oral, because oral is the thing I can do, the thing I’m good at, the thing that doesn’t require my dick to be seen or measured or assessed. I kissed her neck, her collarbone, the top of her chest. I pulled her shirt off. I unclasped her bra—front clasp, easy, I’d practiced—and I kissed her breasts, her stomach, the line of her ribs. I moved down.
She let me. She leaned back on the couch and let me kiss my way down her body, and when I pulled off her pants and her underwear and put my mouth on her, she exhaled—a long, slow, deliberate exhale that said yes, this, keep going.
I ate her pussy for a long time. I was good at it—I knew I was good at it, and the knowing was both a source of pride and a source of sadness, because being good at oral was a compensation, a redirect, a way of being sexual without using the part of me that was inadequate. I used my tongue—circles, flicks, the flat of it, the point of it. I used my fingers—two inside her, curled upward, pressing the spot that I’d learned to find with previous girlfriends, the spot that made women make sounds. I was thorough. I was patient. I was doing the thing I’d spent years perfecting, the thing that made me feel like I could be good at sex even if my dick were small.
She got wet. Very wet. I could feel it on my chin, on my fingers, the slick, warm evidence of her arousal. She was vocal—not performative, not loud-for-the-sake-of-loud, but genuinely, reactively vocal. Sounds coming out of her that she wasn’t scripting, sounds that were being pulled from her by what I was doing with my mouth and hands. She came. Once, twice, three times—I lost count, the orgasms blurring into each other, her body tensing and releasing, her thighs pressing against my ears and then falling open, her hands in my hair pulling and then pushing and then pulling again.
I was hard. I could feel my dick inside my jeans—three inches, straining, as hard as it gets, which is not very hard, not very long, not very much. But I was focused on her. I was in the zone, the oral zone, the safe zone, the part of sex where my mouth was the main event and my dick was hidden and irrelevant.
—
After the third orgasm—or the fourth, or the fifth—she pulled me up. She pulled my face to hers and kissed me, tasting herself on my lips, and she said it.
“I want you to fuck me.”
She said it simply. Directly. The way you say something you want. No hedging, no hinting, just the words, clear and plain, and I felt my stomach drop because the zone was over, the safe part was over, and now we were approaching the part I’d been avoiding.
“Okay,” I said.
I stood up. I undressed. I took off my shirt, my jeans, and then—after a pause I tried to make casual, but it was actually the longest pause of my life—my underwear. I pulled them down, and my dick was there. Small. Hard. Three inches, thin, sticking out from my body with the minimal conviction of a penis that is doing its best and falling short. I didn’t look at her face. I couldn’t. I kept my eyes on the floor, on the wall, on the ceiling, on anything that wasn’t her eyes, because her eyes would be looking down and down was where my dick was and my dick was the thing I didn’t want her to see.
She didn’t say anything. That was—okay. That was fine. That was the best-case scenario, honestly. She didn’t gasp, didn’t laugh, didn’t comment. She just looked and didn’t say anything. The not-saying was its own kind of communication, the kind that I recognized from years of this: the pause, the assessment, the recalibration of expectations that happens when a woman sees a dick that is smaller than she anticipated.
I reached for my jeans. I pulled out a condom—bought earlier that week, carried in my wallet like a talisman, like a promise to myself that tonight would be the night. I opened the wrapper. I rolled it on. The condom was loose. It was always loose—a standard condom on a below-average dick is like a sock on a small foot, extra latex bunching at the tip, the ring not quite tight enough to stay put without help. I smoothed it as best I could. I looked up.
She was on the bed. She was naked. She was on her hands and knees, her back to me, her ass in the air. Doggy position. She’d assumed it without being asked—just turned over and presented herself, ready, waiting, wet from the orgasms I’d given her, expecting the next thing, the thing she’d asked for, the thing I was supposed to be able to do.
I got behind her. I knelt on the bed. I could see her pussy from behind—wet, open, the lips slightly parted, the entrance visible. I could see it, and I wanted it, and I was terrified of it, because getting into it required my dick to do the thing my dick was least equipped to do.
I lined up. I put the tip of my condom-covered dick against her entrance. I pushed.
—
It didn’t go in.
That’s the simple version. The real version is messier, longer, more detailed, more humiliating. The real version is me on my knees behind her, holding my dick with two fingers—because that’s how I hold it, two fingers, thumb and index, because there’s not enough to hold with a full grip—trying to guide it into her pussy and failing. The real version is the tip pressing against her, the warmth and wetness right there, right at the entrance, and my dick not going in. Not because she wasn’t wet—she was very wet, wetter than I’d ever felt a woman, the orgasms having opened her up and slicked her completely. Not because she was too tight—she wasn’t, she was relaxed, ready. But because my dick was too small to navigate the geometry.
Too short to reach past the curve of her ass. Too thin to maintain contact with the opening when I pushed. I’d get the tip in—barely, the very tip, the head maybe halfway—and I’d try to thrust, and the thrust would slide it out. Out and up, the thin shaft slipping along her lips instead of into her, the condom catching on her skin and dragging the whole thing sideways. I’d reposition. I’d try again. I’d get the tip against the opening and push, and the push would send me off to the side, off to the left, off to the right, sliding along the wetness without penetrating, without getting in, without doing the thing that I was there to do.
I tried for what felt like an eternity. In reality, it was probably two minutes—maybe three—but time does the thing it does in moments of humiliation; it stretches, it slows, it makes each second its own individual hell. I was behind her, on my knees, holding my small, condom-covered dick with two fingers, trying to put it in a woman who was waiting for me to put it in, and I couldn’t. I couldn’t reach. I couldn’t angle. I couldn’t find the right position, the right depth, the right alignment. My dick was too short to get past her cheeks—her beautiful, round, full cheeks, the cheeks that I’d been kissing and grabbing minutes earlier—and every time I tried to thrust, the thrust was empty. The thrust was nothing. My hips moved forward, and my dick slid along the outside of her pussy and the condom bunched and the moment passed, and I tried again, and the same thing happened.
She was patient at first. She stayed in position, her head down, her ass up, waiting. She didn’t move. She didn’t push back. She just waited, the way you wait when someone is fumbling with a lock, giving them time, assuming they’ll figure it out. But I wasn’t figuring it out. I was stuck in the same loop—line up, push, slip out, reposition, line up, push, slip out—and the loop was tightening, each failure making the next attempt more frantic, more desperate, more self-aware.
I could feel myself softening. The anxiety was killing my erection—not fully, not completely, but enough. My dick was going from hard to half-hard, from three inches to two and a half, the thinness getting thinner, the condom getting looser, the situation getting worse with every failed attempt. I was losing the thing I needed to do the thing I was trying to do, and the failing caused the losing, and the smallness caused the failing, and the smallness was the thing I couldn’t change.
She turned her head. She looked back at me—over her shoulder, her hair falling across her face—and I saw it. The expression. Not anger, not disgust, not mockery. Something worse. Something quieter. Disappointment. The specific disappointment of a woman who has been eaten out to multiple orgasms and is now ready for penetration and the man behind her can’t provide it—the disappointment of expectation meeting reality.
“It’s okay,” she said. “Don’t worry about it.”
Her voice was flat. Not cold, not cruel, but flat—the voice of a person who is managing a situation, who is choosing to be kind, who is suppressing what she actually feels to make the other person feel less bad. She’d wanted me to fuck her. She’d said it. She’d asked for it. She’d gotten on her hands and knees. And I hadn’t been able to do it. And now she was telling me it was okay, and the telling was worse than anything she could have said, because “it’s okay, don’t worry about it” is what you say to someone who has failed, and she was saying it to me, and I knew what it meant.
It meant: It’s not okay, and I’m worried about it, but I’m not going to say that because you’re already embarrassed and I can see it on your face and in the way your dick is shrinking inside that loose condom and I’m going to be the adult here and end this gracefully.
She sat up. She turned around. She was still naked, still beautiful, still wet. I was kneeling in front of her with a condom on my softening dick, the latex hanging off the tip like an empty finger, the whole apparatus looking ridiculous—the condom designed for a man five times my size, hanging off me like a deflated balloon, and my dick inside it barely visible, a small, soft, retreating nub that was giving up on the project entirely.
“You can take the condom off,” she said. Gently. Like a nurse. Like someone delivering news.
I pulled it off. I pulled the latex down and off, and my dick came free—small, soft, maybe an inch, wet with lubricant, shrinking against my body. I held the used condom in my hand. It was mostly empty. The reservoir tip was intact—unused, unfilled, a small balloon of nothing. I set it on the nightstand. I didn’t look at her.
I recognized, in that moment, with the clarity that comes from rock bottom, that my dick was not going to experience pussy. Not tonight. Not this month. Maybe not this year. Maybe not ever, if this was how it went—if every attempt ended the same way, with the geometry of my smallness defeating the mechanics of sex, with my dick unable to reach, unable to stay in, unable to do the one thing that dicks are supposed to do. The virginity wasn’t going to end tonight. It was going to continue, and the continuation felt like a sentence.
—
She didn’t kick me out. That was something. She didn’t get dressed and make an excuse. She stayed on the bed, naked, and she reached for me—pulled me down, pulled me next to her, put her hand on my dick.
“Let me make you feel good,” she said. “You made me feel good. I want you to have an orgasm too.”
She was being generous. She was being kind. She was being the kind of person who recognizes that the man she’s with has just had a deeply emasculating experience and is trying to give him something back, some scrap of sexual dignity, some proof that his body can still produce a result. She wrapped her hand around my dick—all of it, easily, her fingers enclosing the entire length in one grip, the way you’d hold a small marker or a thick crayon—and she started to stroke.
Her hand felt good. It did. The warmth, the pressure, the rhythm—my body responded, my dick stiffening slightly in her grip, going from soft to half-hard, from an inch to maybe two, the slow, partial, inadequate erection that was the best my body could produce under these circumstances. She stroked, and I felt the pleasure building, faint and distant, the way pleasure builds when the stimulation is gentle, and the organ being stimulated is small.
She tried dirty talk. I’ll give her credit for that—she tried. She was lying next to me, stroking my dick with one hand, and she started talking. Low, soft, the kind of voice you use when you’re trying to create a mood.
“Do you ever think about threesomes?” she asked.
I was surprised. It was a left turn—a question that seemed to come from nowhere, delivered in the middle of a handjob that was already strange, already loaded with the aftermath of my failure. But I answered.
“Yeah,” I said. “Sometimes.”
“What kind?” she asked. “Two girls, or a guy and a girl?”
I thought about it. Honestly, I thought about it—not in the way you think about a fantasy, but in the way you think about a real question, a practical question, a question that requires you to assess your own capabilities. Two girls. Could I satisfy two women? Could I fuck two women, go back and forth, maintain an erection, switch positions, perform? I couldn’t even get into one. I couldn’t maintain an erection with one woman waiting for me in doggy. Two would be—
“I could imagine a threesome with another man,” I said. “I can’t imagine myself satisfying two ladies.”
It came out before I could stop it. The honest answer. The real answer. The answer that acknowledged, out loud, in bed, to a woman I was trying to impress, that I couldn’t satisfy two women. That my dick wasn’t capable of it. That the idea of two women was not a fantasy but a stress test, and I would fail it the way I’d failed tonight.
She was quiet for a moment. Her hand kept moving on my dick—slow, steady, the rhythm unchanged. Then she said it.
“Exactly. It’s good you say that.”
Exactly. The word landed on me. Exactly—as in, yes, that’s what I expected you to say. Exactly—as in, I asked the question because I already knew the answer. Exactly—as in, your dick is small, you can’t satisfy one woman, of course you can’t satisfy two, and it’s good that you know that, it’s good that you’re honest about it, it’s good that you’re not pretending.
She wasn’t being cruel. She was being honest, the way my girlfriend on the plane would later be honest—just saying the true thing, the obvious thing, the thing that was sitting in the room between us. My dick was small. I couldn’t satisfy her. I couldn’t satisfy two women. A threesome with another man made sense because another man could do what I couldn’t—could provide the penetration, the size, the fucking that I was unable to provide. She’d asked the question to confirm what she already knew, and I’d confirmed it, and she’d said exactly, and the exactly was a verdict.
—
She got tired. I could feel it—the hand on my dick slowing, the rhythm becoming inconsistent, the attention waning. She was losing interest, not in me, exactly, but in the project of making me come. The handjob had been generous, a gift, and the gift was running out, and she was ready for it to be over.
“I’m getting a little tired,” she said. Not mean. Just honest. “Do you want to finish yourself?”
She rolled onto her back. She lay next to me, her head on the pillow, her eyes on the ceiling. She was still naked. Her body was still beautiful—breasts, stomach, hips, the body I’d eaten out to multiple orgasms, the body I’d failed to penetrate, the body that was now lying next to me like a landscape I couldn’t enter.
I took my dick in my hand. Two fingers. Thumb and index. The grip I always used, the grip that was the only grip that worked, because my dick was too thin for a full hand, too short for a fist, too small for anything other than two fingers and a frantic, tight, fast motion.
I started to masturbate.
She watched at first. She lay next to me and watched my hand move on my dick—two fingers, pumping fast, the small shaft disappearing and reappearing between my fingers, the motion concentrated in a tiny space, the whole production so different from what she was used to, from what she’d seen in porn, from what she’d experienced with other men. She watched, and I could feel her watching. I could feel what she was seeing: a man lying next to her, furiously jerking off a small dick with two fingers, his whole body tense, his face red, his breathing fast, trying to get there, trying to come, trying to salvage something from the wreckage of the evening.
She lost interest. I could see it happen—the eyes drifting, the attention moving elsewhere. She looked at the ceiling. She looked at her phone. She looked at the wall. She was still next to me, still in the bed, but she was gone. She’d checked out. The show was over, or rather, the show was still going, but the audience had left, and I was performing for no one, my hand moving on my dick in the small, tight, fast rhythm that I’d perfected over years of solitary masturbation.
I was furious. Not at her—at the situation, at my body, at the smallness, at the fact that I was lying next to a naked woman who had asked me to fuck her and instead of fucking her I was jerking off with two fingers while she stared at the ceiling. I was furious, and I was humiliated, and I was aroused. The three things were tangled together in a way I didn’t understand yet—wouldn’t understand for years—the way that shame and arousal overlap, the way that humiliation can feed desire, the way that the worst moments can also be the most intense.
I came. It happened suddenly—the orgasm building fast, the way it does when you’ve been on the edge for a long time, the way it does when the body has been teased and denied and is finally given permission. I felt it rise from my balls, up through the shaft—short, thin, the whole journey maybe two inches—and I came. Hard. The cum shot out of me—more than I expected, the way it sometimes happens, the body compensating for the small delivery mechanism with a surprising volume. It shot up. Across my stomach. A stripe of white from my navel to my chest, warm and thick, pooling in the dip of my sternum. A second spurt, weaker, landing on my stomach. A third, weaker still, dribbling out over my fingers.
I lay there. Breathing. My hand still on my dick, two fingers, the small, softening shaft already retreating, the cum cooling on my torso. I looked at it—the white stripes across my body, the evidence that I had come, that my dick had produced something, that the evening had ended in an orgasm even if it wasn’t the orgasm I’d wanted.
She glanced over. A brief look—a check-in, a confirmation that it was done, that the project was complete, that she could now move to the next phase of the evening, which was clearly going to be sleep.
“Good?” she asked.
“Yeah,” I said. “Yeah. Good.”
—
I cleaned up in her bathroom. I wiped the cum off my stomach with toilet paper. I looked at myself in the mirror—red-faced, sweaty, the face of a man who had eaten a woman to four orgasms and then failed to fuck her and then jerked off next to her while she lost interest. My dick was soft. An inch. Barely visible. A nub. I looked at it in the mirror, and I thought: This is what I have. This is what I’m working with. This is why I couldn’t get inside her.
I went back to the bedroom. She was under the covers. She’d put on a t-shirt. She was on her phone, scrolling, the way you scroll when the evening is over, and you’re transitioning to sleep. She looked up when I came in.
“You can stay if you want,” she said. “Or you can go. Either way.”
I stayed. I lay next to her in the bed, in the dark, and I listened to her breathing slow into sleep. I lay there awake for a long time, staring at the ceiling, feeling the absence of her pussy around my dick—the absence that was going to continue, that was going to be my life, that was the thing I was going to carry.
We didn’t go on another date. She texted me a few days later—friendly, casual, the kind of text you send when you’re closing things out. Hey, had a good time the other night, but I don’t think we’re a match. Good luck out there. I read it, and I knew what it meant. Not a match. Not compatible. The polite version of your dick is too small, and you couldn’t fuck me, and I’m not going to do that again.
I didn’t reply. I lay on my bed, and I held my phone, and I thought about the evening—the oral, the doggy, the condom, the failing, the handjob, the dirty talk, the threesome question, the exactly, the masturbation, the cum on my stomach, the ceiling.
I thought about her voice when she said: “It’s okay, don’t worry about it.” The flatness. The disappointment. The kindness that was worse than cruelty.
I thought about her hand on my dick—her whole hand, enclosing all of it, the ease of the grip, the way my dick disappeared inside her fingers.
I thought about the exactly. The confirmation. The verdict.
I thought about the cum on my stomach—shooting across my torso, the one moment of the evening where my dick had done something, had produced a result, had made its presence known, even if the presence was small and the result was solitary.
I lay there, and I thought about all of it. My dick got hard—three inches, two fingers, the same as always—and I masturbated again, thinking about the failure, thinking about the disappointment, thinking about the exactly. I came again, alone, on my stomach, in my apartment, a virgin still, and the cum was the same, and the dick was the same, and the smallness was the same and nothing had changed except the knowledge that it was true: I couldn’t satisfy a woman. I couldn’t get inside. I couldn’t do the thing.
And the knowledge sat on me like a stone. And I carried it. And I carry it still.
The End.
*The opinions/views expressed in this story (and in any comments) are those of the author and do not represent this site. We support freedom of speech. This story has been submitted directly to this website for publication. Thanks for your submission.