The Nightman Cometh
An SPH Experience by MicroGinger140.
I’d be Dennis, the Dayman. Which meant one thing: spandex. Full, body-hugging, nothing-left-to-the-imagination spandex. I was actually excited about it. Not because I thought I’d look particularly heroic, but because the whole ridiculousness of the costume was the point. Plus, I’d get to do the whole “Dayman, fighter of the Nightman” bit all night.
My girlfriend at the time—we’ll just call her my ex now, but back then she was everything to me—wasn’t really into Halloween. She’d skip the party, maybe hand out candy, but she never dressed up. So when I mentioned it to her, I didn’t expect much reaction.
I didn’t get much of one at first—just a little laugh.
“Yeah, you’re not doing that.”
I didn’t think anything of it. She was always making jokes like that. She’d tease me about my hair, my clothes, the way I danced. It was part of our dynamic. I ordered the costume that night.
A week later, we were sitting on her couch, watching some movie I can’t remember, when I mentioned the costume had been delivered. I was excited. I told her I’d try it on before the party, make sure it fit right, maybe do a test run of the Dayman pose in the mirror.
She went white. Not “oh, that’s surprising” white. More like “I just saw a ghost, and it’s standing in my living room” white. Her whole body tensed up.
“You’re not really wearing that, are you?” she asked, her voice a little too high, a little too fast.
I frowned. “Yeah. I told you that.”
“No.” She was already shaking her head before the word even fully left her mouth. “Please don’t.”
“Why not? You said you didn’t want to dress up this year.”
“I don’t. That’s not—” She stopped, bit her lip, tried again. “Just please don’t wear that costume. I’ll dress up. I’ll do a couple’s thing. Anything. Just not that.”
I should have let it go. Maybe if I had, we’d have had a different conversation—a gentler one. But I was confused, and a little annoyed. We’d been together for over a year at that point. I thought I knew her, and I thought she knew me. But the way she was looking at me—like I was about to walk into traffic—made no sense.
“What is your problem?” I asked. “It’s just a costume.”
“It’s not just a costume.”
“Then what is it?”
She looked away. That’s when I knew something was actually wrong. Not annoying-wrong, but real-wrong. She never looked away. She was the kind of person who held eye contact like it was a competition.
“You have to tell me,” I said, softer now. “Come on. What’s going on?”
She kept her head turned, her fingers picking at the edge of a throw pillow. Her breathing had gone shallow, like she was trying not to cry. I reached over and put my hand on her knee.
“Hey. Seriously. What’s wrong?”
She looked back at me then, and there were tears in her eyes. Real ones. I’d only seen her cry a handful of times—when her grandmother died, when we had our first big fight, when she’d had too much wine and started talking about her dad. This was different. This was a slow, leaking kind of sadness. The kind that comes from having to say something you’ve been carrying for a long time.
“Everyone is gonna see,” she whispered.
“See what?”
She took a shaky breath. Her voice dropped so low I had to lean in to hear her.
“Babe, it’s spandex. And I love you. You know I do. I don’t mind it. But everyone is gonna see how small you are. People are gonna take pictures. They’re gonna laugh behind my back. Please just don’t wear it.”
I didn’t say anything. I couldn’t. It felt like all the air had been sucked out of the room.
She wasn’t done.
“I’m not trying to be mean. I’m not. I know it’s not something you can change. But you don’t understand what it’s like. You don’t see the way people look at me. The way my friends look at me when I talk about you. They’ll see that costume, and they’ll know. Everyone will know.”
“Know what?” My voice came out flat. Hollow.
She closed her eyes. “That you’re not… that you don’t have… you know.”
I did know. Of course I knew. I’d known since middle school, since the first time I’d had to change for gym class and realized that the other guys had something I didn’t. Something more. I’d spent years perfecting the quick-change, the towel-hug, the strategic angle. I’d accepted it, the way you accept any permanent flaw. But hearing it from her—hearing the woman I loved say the words out loud—that was different.
That was a door closing.
“I would never ask you to change,” she said, and she actually reached for my hand. “I love you. I love everything about you. I just… I can’t handle everyone seeing it. Hand to God, that’s the only reason I don’t want you to wear it. You deserve to feel good about yourself. You do. But that costume…”
She trailed off, shaking her head again.
“It would be bad, babe. Really bad.”
I sat there, letting it sink in. The woman I loved was crying because she was afraid of what my body would look like in a Halloween costume. Not because she found me unattractive. Not because she wanted me to change. But because she was embarrassed. Because she couldn’t handle the thought of other people seeing what she’d been quietly dealing with for over a year.
“I asked her if it was really that bad,” I said later, when I was alone, replaying the conversation in my head. I didn’t have to ask. I knew the answer. But I needed to hear her say it.
“It’s not bad,” she’d said, her voice catching. “It’s not. It’s just… small. You know it’s small. I know it’s small. That’s fine. It works for us. But it’s not something I want the whole world to see.”
I’d sat with that for a moment. Then I’d asked the question I should have never asked.
“Are you embarrassed by me?”
She’d been quiet for a long time. Long enough that I thought she wouldn’t answer.
“Not by you,” she’d finally said. “By… that part of you. Sometimes.”
And then, because she couldn’t stop herself, because the dam had already broken, she told me the part that really cut deep.
“I talked to one of my friends about it when we first started dating. She didn’t believe me. She said I was exaggerating. Because she knew the other guys I’d been with and what I was used to. She thought I was joking.”
She looked at me, tears still streaming, and whispered:
“I wasn’t.”
We sat there for what felt like hours. We didn’t talk about the costume anymore. I don’t know if we ever really talked about it again. We just sat there, her crying softly, me staring at the wall, both of us realizing that something had shifted between us.
That night, we tried to have sex. I don’t know why. Maybe we both thought it would fix something. Maybe we just needed to feel close. But I couldn’t get hard. Every time she touched me, all I could hear was her voice saying, “Everyone is gonna see how small you are.” All I could see was her friend’s face, laughing, thinking she was exaggerating.
She tried everything. Her hands first, gentle and familiar. Then her mouth, working harder than she ever had before. But nothing. I lay there, soft and small and completely unable to perform, while she did her best not to look disappointed.
“It’s okay,” she kept saying. “It’s fine. It happens to everyone.”
But we both knew why it was happening. We both knew that my body had internalized what my brain was struggling to process. The woman I loved had just told me she was embarrassed by my dick. Not in a cruel way. Not in a malicious way. But honestly, openly, with tears in her eyes.
That’s not something you just bounce back from.
It took almost a month before I could get hard with her again. And when I finally did, it was wrong somehow. The intimacy was different. She’d touch me, and I’d go soft, remembering. Or I’d touch her, and she’d be too gentle, too careful, as if she were handling something fragile. We started having less sex. Then, eventually, no sex at all.
The relationship limped along for a few more months. We’d go out to dinner, watch movies, visit her friends. But something had gone out of us. We were going through the motions, playing a part, pretending that the conversation in her living room hadn’t happened.
She ended it on a Tuesday. I remember it was a Tuesday because I had a dentist appointment that morning, and when she called, I was still numb from the Novocain.
“It’s not about that night,” she said. “It’s about everything. We’ve grown apart. You know we have.”
I knew. We both knew.
The funny thing—if you can call it that—is that she was so sad about telling me the truth. Before the breakup, she was gentle and apologetic, like she’d confessed some horrible crime and was waiting for sentencing. She held my hand. She told me she loved me. She swore she’d never meant to hurt me.
But after we broke up? Different story.
About a year after the split, I got a message from her—just a link. No explanation. I clicked on it and found myself on some Tumblr page where people posted anonymous messages to their exes. Sad stuff, mostly. Regretful, remorseful, the usual post-breakup melancholy. She’d posted something about missing me, about how she’d fucked things up, about how she wished she could go back and do it differently.
I don’t think she realized I could click her user ID and see everything else she’d posted.
I should have stopped there. I should have closed the page and moved on with my life. But I didn’t. I scrolled. And that’s when I found it.
“It’s such a shame you turned out to be such a pussy, especially since your little dick could never figure out mine.”
The words hit me like a punch to the gut. This was the same woman who’d cried in my arms because she was afraid of humiliating me. The same woman who’d promised she loved every part of me. The same woman who’d spent an hour trying to get me hard and then sworn it didn’t matter.
And there it was, in plain text, for anyone to see: her real thoughts. The ones she’d been too kind to say when we were together. The ones that had been building up for years. The ones that made her sadness during that Halloween conversation feel like a performance.
She wasn’t sad because she hurt me. She was sad because she’d been forced to admit that her boyfriend had a small dick—and that she’d stayed with him anyway.
The comments under her post were worse.
“sounds like my ex lol”
“girl you deserve better”
“small dicks should come with a warning label”
“at least you got out when you did”
She didn’t respond to any of them. But she didn’t delete them, either. She left them there, a little shrine to her disappointment.
I closed the tab eventually. I sat there in my apartment, alone, and let it all wash over me. The humiliation, the anger, the weird, empty vindication of having known—somewhere deep down—that my own embarrassment wasn’t just in my head.
I never wore that costume. It’s still in my closet, in the original packaging. I couldn’t bring myself to return it, and I couldn’t bring myself to put it on—some things you just can’t un-know.
I don’t celebrate Halloween anymore. My friends always ask why, and I always give them some excuse—busy with work, not into it this year, got other plans. They’ve stopped asking.
Maybe one day I’ll tell them the truth. Maybe one day I’ll tell anyone the truth.
But for now, the truth stays where it belongs: buried in a costume I never wore, in a conversation I can’t forget, and in the words of a woman who loved me just enough to feel sorry for me, but not enough actually to stand by me.
The Nightman Cometh, all right.
He came in the form of a spandex costume and a tearful admission that my little dick was a secret she couldn’t keep.
And the Dayman? The Dayman never showed up at all.
The End.

