SPH-THEMED EROTICA STORIES

I know I’m good-looking. That’s not arrogance—it’s just arithmetic. I’ve had strangers—women, mostly, but sometimes couples—ask to take photos with me at bars or festivals. I get invited to house parties by people I’ve met twice. I’ve had numbers pressed into my palm without asking, sometimes with a wink and a “call me.” I’ve been propositioned in coffee shops, at the gym, and on the train. It happens often enough that I’ve stopped being surprised.

And I’ve had sex. A fair amount. Not as much as I could have, because I turn down a lot of opportunities, but enough to know the pattern by heart.

The pattern goes like this: we meet, we click, the conversation flows. She laughs at my jokes, touches my arm, leans in close. I feel the electric hum of possibility, the way her eyes travel over my face, my shoulders, my hands. I’m tall enough, broad-shouldered, with a jaw that photographs well and eyes that catch light. The attention is warm, flattering, addictive. I ride that wave for a while—a few dates, maybe a week of texting—and then we end up in bed.

The lights are low. We’re kissing. Her hands are on my chest, my back, sliding down my stomach. My cock is already hard—three inches, exactly, if I hold the ruler flush against my pubic bone. It’s basically just the head, a mushroom cap perched on a tiny stalk. When I’m soft, which is most of the time, it’s barely half an inch—a little button hiding in my pubes.

I know what’s coming. I’ve been through this dozens of times.

Her hand finds it. And here’s the moment: the moment her fingers wrap around it, and she feels how small it is. The way her touch hesitates for a fraction of a second—that tiny pause where her brain catches up to her senses. Then her hand closes, and she tries to recover, stroking it like it’s normal, like she didn’t just measure me and find me wanting.

I watch her face when we shift positions. Her excited smile—the one that said I’m about to get fucked—drops. Just a little. A flicker. She tries to hide it, but I’ve seen it so many times I could paint it from memory. Her eyebrows twitch. Her lips press together. She says something like, “Oh, that’s… cute,” or “Size doesn’t matter, you know,” or “I like when they don’t hurt, so this is perfect.”

I nod. I pretend to believe her.

And then I fuck her, or she rides me, and it’s fine. It’s okay. She feels something—I know how to use my tongue, my fingers, my mouth—but I can feel the lack. The incredible absence. The way her hips move differently, searching for something that isn’t there. The way she reaches down to guide me, and her fingers find nothing but my pubic bone. The way she looks up at the ceiling during missionary, her eyes glazed, not with pleasure but with resignation.

Afterward, she’s nice. She cuddles. She says it was good. She might even mean it, in a way—orgasms aren’t just about penetration, and I’m good with my hands. But I know what happens next. She goes home, texts her friend, and says something like, “He was hot, but his dick was tiny,” or “I mean, it was literally like a thumb,” or worse. I’ve overheard it once or twice, by accident. I’ve seen the pitying looks exchanged between women who think I’m not watching.

I’m tired of it. Tired of waiting until the lights are off, pretending I’m bigger in the dark. Tired of bringing out the toys—vibrators, dildos—just to give her what I can’t. Tired of the performance, the careful choreography of angles and positions to make three inches feel like something more.

So I’ve stopped. I just masturbate. It’s easier—no disappointment, no performance, no moment when her smile drops. I jerk off in the shower, or in bed with my laptop open, and I don’t have to explain anything to anyone.

But then everyone asks why I’m single.

“You’re such a catch,” my coworker Lisa said last week, leaning over my desk. “Handsome, funny, good job. I know a woman you should meet. She’s perfect for you.”

I smiled. I said, “I’m not really looking right now.”

She waved a hand. “Oh, come on. Everyone’s looking. I’ll give her your number.”

I didn’t say no. I never say no. Because what am I supposed to say? I can’t date because my dick is too small? That’s not a thing you say out loud. So I take the number, I let the setups happen, and I go through the motions—coffee, dinner, maybe a second date—until the inevitable bedroom moment, and then I ghost, or I make an excuse, or I let the relationship fizzle into nothing.

Last month, my sister’s best friend, Debbie, cornered me at a family barbecue. “Why are you still single?” she demanded, arms crossed. “You’re like, ridiculously attractive. It’s weird.”

I shrugged. “Haven’t found the right person.”

“Bullshit,” she said. “You’re scared. What are you scared of?”

I wanted to tell her. I wanted to pull down my shorts right there on the patio and show her the little mushroom head I’m hiding under my jeans. I wanted to say, This is what I’m scared of. This three-inch joke makes women’s faces fall. This half-inch button looks like a birth defect when I’m soft. I’m scared of another night of pretending, another morning of knowing she’s telling her friends, another text that never comes.

But I didn’t. I laughed, changed the subject, and spent the rest of the barbecue avoiding Debbie’s knowing eyes.

The worst part isn’t the rejection. It’s the anticipation. It’s knowing that every woman who approaches me, every number I get, every spark of chemistry—they all lead to the same destination: the moment when her hand wraps around my cock and her face says everything her mouth won’t.

I’m tired of disappointing people. I’m tired of being a pretty face with a pathetic secret. I’m tired of the pity fucks, the careful compliments, the women who say “it’s perfect the way it is” while their eyes are already scrolling through mental exit strategies.

So I stay home. I jerk off. I tell my friends I’m just not ready to date.

And they keep bringing me names, keep pushing me toward women who don’t know what they’re signing up for. “You’d be perfect together,” they say. “She’s smart, funny, beautiful.”

I smile. I take the number. I stuff it in my pocket next to the others.

And I wonder how long I can keep this up before someone finally asks the question I’m dreading: What’s really wrong with you?

 

The End.

*The opinions/views expressed in this story (and in any comments) are those of the author and do not represent this site. We support freedom of speech. This story has been submitted directly to this website so that we can publish it here. Thanks for your submission.