SPH Experiences: My Girl Cheated On Me
By Commercial_Mix_3788.
We’ve been together three years. She’s the first girl who ever made me feel like I wasn’t a total loser in a relationship. Smart as hell — she’s finishing her master’s in Pharmacy(or whatever it’s called) while I’m still grinding a Good County job. Gorgeous, funny, the kind of girl who walks into a room and every guy turns. I’m average-looking at best, 5’11”, dad-bod starting to creep in at 28 after being a college athlete. She’s way out of my league, and I’ve known it since day one.
On our very first date, she straight-up told me: “Look, I’ve had a lot of fun in my life. A LOT. I was kind of a whore in college and my early 20s. But I’m done with that. If we do this, I’m loyal. I promise.” I laughed it off like an idiot. She said the number once when we were drunk — she was my third GF ever. She’s been with… yeah, like 80+ guys. She laughed when she said it, like it was cute. I told myself it didn’t matter because she chose me. Also, I guess I appreciated the honesty. She is also Bipolar, which explains a lot. It can be bad, including hallucinations, wide mood swings, and a high sex drive.
Sexually? I’ve always known I’m… not big. Like, legitimately small. 4 inches on a good day, and even then, I struggle to stay hard enough for real penetration. She’s never complained — at least not to my face. I’m obsessed with making her cum. I eat her out for hours, finger her until my wrist cramps, and we have every toy you can imagine. She’s always told me I’m the best she’s ever had at that stuff. “No one’s ever taken care of me as you do,” she’d moan while I was between her legs. I believed her.
Until last month.
She left her phone on the kitchen counter while she was in the shower. I wasn’t even snooping — I just needed to check the time because mine was charging. The screen was open to her hidden folder (the one she thinks I don’t know the passcode for — it’s her mom’s birthday, genius). And there it was. A video. 31 minutes and 47 seconds. Thumbnail: her face, eyes rolled back, mouth open in a scream I have literally never heard from her in three years.
I shouldn’t have clicked. I know that. But I did.
The video starts with her on our bed — the same gray sheets we still sleep on every night — on all fours. This guy (I couldn’t see his face at first) is behind her, and holy fuck. The dick. It was… cartoonish. Thick, long, veiny, easily twice my size. Maybe more. He wasn’t even all the way in yet, and she was already shaking. Then he pushed in, and she let out this noise — half scream, half sob — that made my stomach drop through the floor.
“Fuck, yes, daddy — god you’re so much bigger than him,” she moaned. Him. Me. She said it out loud.
For the next thirty minutes, I watched my girlfriend of three years get fucked in every position I’ve ever tried to do with her and failed at. She rode him reverse cowgirl, grinding down until her ass was flush against his hips, screaming his name (some dude named “Alex” or “Alec,” I still don’t know). She deep-throated him while looking straight at the camera, as if she were performing. She came so hard she squirted — something she’s never done with me, not once. At one point, he had her folded in half, pounding her so deeply her eyes were crossing, and she was babbling “I’m yours, I’m yours, I’m yours” over and over.
I sat on the bathroom floor with her phone in my shaking hands and cried like a little bitch the entire time. Full ugly sobs. Snot running down my face. And then… I got hard. Rock fucking hard. Harder than I’ve been in months.
The shame hit me like a truck. I felt disgusting. What the fuck is wrong with me? My girlfriend is cheating on me in our bed, and I’m getting off to it? I wanted to throw up and stroke myself at the same time—truly deplorable behavior.
That night, I planned the confrontation. I rehearsed it in the mirror. I was going to be calm but firm. Show her the video. Ask her how long it’s been going on. Tell her I deserved better. I even wrote down bullet points like a fucking loser.
The next day, she came home from class, kissed me on the cheek, made my favorite pasta, and cuddled up to me on the couch like nothing was wrong. She told me how much she missed me and how no one makes her feel as safe as I do. I melted. I couldn’t do it. The words died in my throat. I was a total utter coward.
It’s been 37 days.
Every single day, I tell myself, “Today’s the day.” Every single night, I watch the video again. Sometimes twice. I’ve made a secret folder on my own phone with screenshots and a screen recording. I hate myself for it. I tell myself I’m keeping it as proof.
I keep telling myself it might be an old video. Maybe from before we were serious? But the sheets are the new ones we bought last year. Her hair is the length it is now. The plant in the corner is the one I bought her for Valentine’s. It’s recent. I know it is.
She still fucks me sometimes — or at least lets me go down on her. And every time she moans, I hear the ghost of that other moan in my head. I know I’ll never make her sound like that. I’m not enough. I never was.
My friends warned me from the jump. “Bro, she’s hot, but she’s been passed around more than the office stapler.” “She’ll cheat, they always do when they’ve had that many bodies,” I told them they were jealous. I told myself I was different. I was the one who was on her side. Dating a gamble, no pain, no gain.
Turns out I was just the safe, pathetic placeholder who’s good with his tongue and pays the rent.
I still love her. That’s the worst part. Even knowing what she did — and probably keeps doing — I love her. If she broke up with me tomorrow, I’d still love her. I’d probably beg to stay friends just to talk to her. I’m that much of a spineless cuck.
I don’t know what I’m asking here. Advice? Validation? Someone to call me the fucking idiot I clearly am? I just needed to type this all out because keeping it inside is eating me alive. I’m scared to confront her because then it becomes real. Then I have to leave. Then I’m alone again, and the idea of going back to dating apps as a guy who already knows he’s not enough… it makes me want to die.
So yeah. That’s my life right now. I sleep next to the girl I love every night, knowing she’s getting railed by someone else who actually fills her up, and instead of doing anything about it, I just… watched it happen. I haven’t done anything about it.
Thanks for reading if you made it this far. I’m a fucking mess, please don’t make fun of me. I know I have some deep fucking issues I need to work on.
The End.
*The opinions/views expressed in this story (and in any comments) are those of the author and do not represent this site. We support freedom of speech. This story was previously published on other free websites (e.g., Reddit) and is now in the public domain, allowing us to republish it here.