SPH-THEMED EROTICA STORIES

It was one of those days where the horniness hit like a fever. I’d woken up hard, stayed hard through my shower, and by noon I’d rubbed one out just to function—and it did absolutely nothing. I was still pacing my apartment with a chub swinging in my sweatpants, thinking about getting fucked so hard I’d forget my own name. So I did what any reasonable gay man does when his hole starts making decisions for him: I said “fuck it,” re-downloaded one of the hookup apps I’d deleted in a moment of self-improvement delusion, and started swiping.

It didn’t take long. My city has a healthy population of men looking to blow a load on a Tuesday afternoon, and within twenty minutes I’d matched with a guy whose profile was mostly torso—gym-built, nice chest, face conveniently cropped out. His one dick pic showed a perfectly fine cock. Nothing spectacular. Honestly, on the shorter and thinner side—my rough estimate put it around four and three-quarter inches long, maybe four around. But it was clean, it was hard, and it was attached to a body that clearly put in work. On a day like today, “fine” was going to get the job done.

I sent him a few pictures of myself. Ass up, cheeks spread, my hole on full display. His response came back in under a minute, and it was desperate in a way that should have been my first clue.

“Holy fuck. Please let me breed that. Please. I need it.”

Three messages in a row. Begging. I’ll admit, something is flattering about a stranger groveling for your hole, even if the cock doing the begging was more modest than what I usually went for. I told him sure, I was ready if he was, cleaned out and waiting.

“At the gym rn. Leaving NOW.”

I threw on some porn to keep myself warmed up and waited. Maybe forty minutes later, there was a knock at the door. I texted him that it was open and just to push it, then positioned myself face-down on the bed, ass toward the door, eyes on my phone. I wasn’t trying to be cold—it’s just easier that way. No awkward eye contact, no small talk, no performance of chemistry that isn’t there. He walks in, he gets what he came for, everyone goes about their day.

I heard the door push open, footsteps, the rustle of a gym bag hitting my floor. I kept my eyes glued to my phone screen, watching some bottom get railed while I waited for hands on me. When they came, they were confident—big warm palms spreading my cheeks, thumbs dragging over my hole, circling, pressing. He spat on it, and I felt the wet warmth of it drip down over my taint. His fingers pushed in, two at first, working me open with an eagerness that bordered on gratitude. I heard him groan behind me, heard the slick sound of him stroking himself hard.

“You want me to use a condom?” he asked.

“Sure,” I said, still not looking. “Nightstand. Few in there.”

I heard the drawer open, the tear of foil. Then the blunt, rubber-wrapped head of his cock nudging against my spit-slick hole, pushing in.

And that’s when he started talking.

“That’s it, take it, fuck, you feel so good—”

I froze.

Not because of what he said. Because of the voice. That specific cadence, that slight nasal drag on the vowels, the way he said “fuck” like it had three syllables. I knew that voice. I’d known that voice for three years of my twenties. I’d fallen asleep to that voice. I’d had screaming fights with that voice.

It was my ex. It was Cole.

A full decade. Ten years since I’d last seen him, and here he was, balls-deep in my ass in my new apartment, a city we’d apparently both ended up in, and he had no idea—because I’d never once turned around or let him see my face.

I should have stopped it there. Any sane person would have. But look—I was horny, he was already inside me, and honestly? The sheer absurdity of it was doing something for me. There’s a special kind of poetry in your ex begging to breed you without knowing it’s you. So I bit the pillow and let him fuck.

And fuck, he did. Or attempted to. He had a rhythm going, hips snapping against my ass, and he was talking the whole time, getting filthier by the thrust.

“God, I want to take this condom off. I want to feel you raw. Can I? Tell me I can.”

Here’s the thing about me: I’m on PrEP, have been for years, and I don’t bottom for strangers raw without them knowing my status and me knowing theirs—but this was a moment of pure, petty curiosity. I wanted to see what he’d do.

“I’m on PrEP,” I told him, voice muffled into the pillow, pitched just different enough. “You’re welcome to.”

That was apparently the last straw for him. He made a sound like a dying animal, yanked the condom off, and shoved back in bare.

“Oh fuck, your pussy feels so good,” he groaned, and really started going at it, hammering away like he was trying to prove something.

And I followed along, because that’s what you do. “It’s amazing,” I gasped into the pillow. “Fuck, you feel so good.”

Here’s what I didn’t say:

His dick kept slipping out.

Every handful of thrusts, he’d pull back a little too far and pop right out of me, and there’d be this frantic scramble—him grabbing his cock, fumbling at my hole, jabbing at the wrong spot twice before sinking back in. It happened once. Then again. Then a third time, at which point I stopped counting and started cataloging. My hole was wet and open and practically holding the door open for him, and he still couldn’t stay inside me. There was just not enough dick to stay anchored. Every withdrawal was a gamble. Every re-entry was a coin flip.

And the whole time, with him panting about how good my pussy was, one thought was running on a loop in my head:

Damn. I can see why you were this eager to come over. You probably haven’t gotten to fuck in a while with that little dick, have you?

Because that’s the thing about a four-and-three-quarter-inch cock on a hookup app: it begs. It begs because it has to. Guys like me swipe left on it nine times out of ten, and every once in a while, on a desperate day, we swipe right—and then this happens. A decade of hookups where he’s popping out of every hole he rents, where bottoms are checking their phones over his shoulder, where he’s working twice as hard for half the impact. No wonder he left the gym mid-workout. No wonder he said please three times. This was probably the most action his little cock had seen in months.

I could feel him, technically. That’s the generous way to put it. There was something in there, moving. But he wasn’t hitting anything. Not my prostate, not any wall, not any nerve ending that mattered. It was like being fingered by someone with a very enthusiastic, very short finger. My dick had gone soft ten minutes ago out of what I can only assume was boredom. Meanwhile he’s back there grunting like he’s splitting me open, and I’m lying there with my face in a pillow, doing the work every bottom has done since the dawn of time.

Stock moans. “Oh fuck.” “Right there.” A well-timed “oh my god.” And my personal favorite, deployed every time I felt him start to slow down or, God forbid, slip out again:

“You like that, baby?”

I said it the way you talk to a dog doing a trick. Affirming. Encouraging. Utterly detached. And it worked every time—he’d perk up, grab my hips harder, and start jackhammering with everything his little guy had, which was, again, not much. I was basically a cheerleader for a cock that couldn’t reach the end zone. Meanwhile, my own dick lay against my stomach as it had fainted.

To his credit, he didn’t last long after going raw. Then again, with the pace he was setting and the amount of slipping out he was doing, I’m not sure “lasting” was the right frame—it was more like his cock was sprinting a series of very short races. He pulled out (successfully this time, since he was already halfway out), ripped off what was left of his composure, and came on my lower back. I felt the splatter, warm and anticlimactic, followed by a long, shuddering exhale as he’d just finished a marathon instead of a five-minute stumble-fuck.

“Thank you,” he said. Actually said thank you. Like I’d done him a favor. Like I’d donated to a charity.

“You’re welcome,” I said into the pillow, and I swear I heard my own deadpan echo off the walls.

He cleaned up in my bathroom, got dressed, grabbed his gym bag, and let himself out. I lay there on my stomach, cum cooling on my back, hole wet and open and profoundly unbothered, and I just… lay there for a minute.

And then I started laughing—really laughing—the kind where you have to wipe your eyes.

Because here’s the punchline, the one he never got to hear: I knew that voice because I’d dumped that man ten years ago for the exact reason my ass had just spent twenty minutes politely declining to hold onto him. His dick is too small. It was too small then, and it’s too small now, and apparently in the intervening decade. At the same time, I’d moved apartments and changed gyms and grown into a man who knows exactly what he needs to get off; Cole had been out there in the same city, going to the gym, building that nice chest, taking that same modest little photo, and begging strangers to let him breed them—because that’s the economy you live in when you’re working with four and three-quarter inches. You don’t get to be picky. You say please. You say thank you. You come over the second someone says yes.

The disappointing part wasn’t even him, really. I could feel him, sure. But feeling a dick and getting fucked are two different things, and I’d spent the whole session in that dead zone between them—aware of the friction, receiving none of the payoff. No depth, no stretch, no pressure where it counts. Just a warm little presence, popping in and out like a guest who keeps forgetting why he walked into the room.

So I did what any self-respecting size queen does after a disappointing delivery: I wiped his cum off my back, picked up my phone, and opened the app right back up.

This time I swiped with purpose. I wanted length. I wanted girth. I wanted a cock that would stay inside me without a lifeline, that would punch my prostate on every stroke, that would make me earn every one of my moans instead of manufacturing them from spare parts. I found him within the hour—a guy with an honest eight inches and a smirk in his profile pic who lived fifteen minutes away.

And as I sent him my address, I caught myself grinning at the ceiling, still shaking my head.

A decade. Ten years, one app, one city, and out of every horny man within a five-mile radius, the universe dealt me my ex and his little dick—small world.

Smaller dick.

 

The End.

 

*The opinions/views expressed in this story (and in any comments) are those of the author and do not represent this site. We support freedom of speech. This story has been submitted directly to this website for publication. Thanks for your submission.