He Was Measuring It Wrong

A Gay SPH Confession by NoLab5910.

Adult content warning. Under 18? Click to leave this website.

I’m not usually hung up on numbers. But when a Grindr guy messages you “5” hard, only average lol,” you notice. My own hard dick is 7.5 inches—measured the correct way, from the top, bone-pressed—so a “5” wouldn’t even reach my head if we stacked them. Still, I don’t mind smaller. Sometimes it’s hot. So I replied.

We swapped pics early. My picture: my cock in my hand, thick enough that my fingers didn’t close around the base, the head a wet, ruddy mushroom peeking past my fist. His picture: dim bathroom light, fingers wrapped around a slim little thing that looked maybe four inches, tops. But camera angles are liars. I didn’t care. I told him he had a nice dick, and he said, “Thanks, I know it’s only average. Hope that’s okay.” I said, “If you’re into the size thing, we can play that up.” He sent back a question mark. I figured he was shy.

We met at his place. He was cute—nervous, lanky, chewing his lip. He offered me a beer. We chatted about nothing. Then I brought it up again: “So, five inches.”

He nodded, almost proud. “Yeah. Average. Maybe a touch under, but basically five.”

I smirked. “You don’t have to pretend with me. I’m into the small-dick stuff if you are.”

He blinked. “I’m not small. I’m average.”

I thought he was committing to the bit. “Right. Average. Five.”

“Exactly,” he said, and he meant it.

That’s when it clicked: he wasn’t playing. He actually believed it. So I asked to see. He stood, unzipped, and fished out his cock. Soft, it was a little nub. When he started stroking, it hardened to its full length—maybe the size of my middle finger, if I were being generous, though too, with a small, shiny head. He looked at me for approval.

“Can I measure?” I asked.

He shrugged. “If you want.”

I pulled a tailor’s tape from my bag. I knelt in front of him, took his warm little shaft between my thumb and forefinger, and placed the zero end at the base. “How do you measure?”

He pointed to the underside. “From here. Where the shaft starts, above my balls.”

“Ah. There it is.” I ran the tape along the bottom, from the middle of his sack to the tip. It read 5.1 inches. “You’re measuring from the balls.”

He frowned. “That’s where it starts.”

“No, that’s where your skin starts. The actual penis starts at the pubic bone.” I pressed the tape flat into the top side of his shaft, right at the root above his cock. The end dug into the little fat pad. His dick twitched. I snugged the tape along the top to the tip. “Three and a half inches.”

He stared down. “That can’t be right.”

“It’s the standard. From the pubic bone, top side. You’ve been adding an inch and a half of ballsack.” I held up the tape so he could read the number. 3.5. “Dude, you’re not average. You’re small.”

His face went through about six emotions. Embarrassment. Denial. Then a slow, crushing realization. “Oh.”

I squeezed his cock gently. It was so short my fist completely swallowed it. “But look—it’s a cute little thing. And I’m still here.”

He let out a shaky breath. “You still want to…?”

“Yeah,” I said. “I didn’t come here for a ruler.”

We moved to his bedroom. I stripped first. My cock swung out, already half-hard from the whole measuring scene. He stared. “Fuck, that’s big.”

“Seven and a half,” I said. “Proper top measure.”

I stepped closer and took his little hard-on in one hand, pressing it against my own shaft. Side by side, the difference was almost funny. The head of my cock rose a full four inches past his tip. His entire hard length barely covered the base of my shaft. Two of his stacked end-to-end still wouldn’t equal me. He looked down at the comparison, and his breath hitched.

He knelt without being asked, which was a good sign. I sat on the edge of his bed and let him get to work. He wrapped both hands around my shaft—they didn’t overlap—and licked from my balls to my slit. His mouth was warm and wet. He took the head first, then pushed down, inch by inch, until my cock hit the back of his throat. He gagged, pulled off, then tried again. Third try, he swallowed me to the root, nose pressed into my pubes, throat fluttering around my length. I put a hand on the back of his head. “Fuck, that’s good. You’ve done this before?”

He came up gasping, spit stringing from his lip. “A little. Not like this.”

“Uh-huh. Could’ve fooled me.” I took hold of my cock and tapped the wet head against his cheek. My shaft reached from his chin to the top of his forehead. “This is what seven and a half looks like. Your little nub wouldn’t even touch my navel if I laid it on my stomach.”

He moaned, actually moaned, and went back to sucking. I let him. He was sloppy and eager, using his tongue more than his lips, and when he deepthroated me again, his throat constricted around the ridge of my head. I could have come right there, but I wanted to return the favor.

I pulled him up and pushed him onto the bed. His hard cock stood up from a thatch of dark hair—barely three and a half inches, maybe the thickness of two fingers. I knelt between his legs and took the entire thing into my mouth in one go. His whole shaft fit inside, and my lips still had room before hitting his pubic bone. I could press my nose into his stomach and still have his little head tickling the roof of my mouth. I sucked him slow, swirling my tongue, and he writhed under me, gasping.

“Look at you,” I said, pulling off with a wet pop. “My dick is double yours. I could use yours as a handle.”

He covered his face with his hands, but his cock was leaking. I licked the clear bead from the tip. “Don’t hide. It’s hot.”

We messed around like that for a while—me fingering him open while he sucked my cock again, his little erection bobbing uselessly against his stomach. I didn’t fuck him; he wasn’t ready, and I didn’t want to rush a first-timer. But I came down his throat while he swallowed every drop, and then I finished him with my hand, two fingers and a thumb enough to milk his tiny prick until he shot a thin, watery load over my knuckles.

Afterward, we lay side by side, breathing hard. He spoke into the ceiling. “That was my first time. With a guy. At all.”

I turned my head. “First time? Like, anything?”

“Anything,” he said.

“Shit. You picked a big one to start.”

He laughed, but it caught in his throat. “Yeah. I guess I did.”

We cleaned up. He sat at the foot of the bed, looking at his own soft dick—now a stubby acorn, maybe an inch and a half, retracted into a little pouch of skin. “So I’m not average.”

“No,” I said. “You’re not.”

He was quiet. Then: “I have a small dick.”

“No shit, Sherlock.”

That made him laugh—a real one. “Fuck. I’ve been telling people I was five inches for years. I measured from the bottom because it made me feel better.”

“Most guys do some version of that. But the top method is the only one that counts.” I reached over and took his soft cock between my thumb and forefinger, lifting it. “Three and a half hard. You’d need to stack two of yours to reach my head. Even soft, I’m over four. You saw.”

He looked at my crotch. My spent cock lay thick against my thigh, still longer than his erection had been. “Yeah. I saw.”

We exchanged numbers—well, we already had them from Grindr, but we agreed to keep talking. After I left, the texts started coming in.

Him: thanks for tonight. and for the measuring thing. weird but good?

Me: good weird. you still thinking about it?

Him: kinda. i keep looking at my dick and seeing 3.5 now

Me: good. that’s what it is. a cute little dicklet. not average. small.

Him: stop

Me: why? You know it turns you on. You moaned when I said your nub wouldn’t reach my navel.

Him: fuck. okay maybe

Me: send me a picture. let me see the little guy from the top angle this time.

A pause. Then a photo. His hard cock, three and a half inches, with the tape lying next to it showing exactly 3.5. He’d even held it by the head, making it look even smaller in his fingers.

Me: pathetic. I could hold that between two fingers and still have room. My cock is literally twice that. more. Want to see?

I sent him a fresh pic: my next hard-on, 7.5 inches, lying along my stomach, the head past my navel. Next to it, for scale, I’d laid a can of deodorant. The difference was absurd.

Him: jesus. that’s not fair

Me: no it’s not. but your mouth handled it so well. wish you were here to choke on it again.

Him: i wish i was too

Me: then come back. I’ll let you measure it again. Maybe I’ll measure you with my hand as a unit. Your whole dick fits in one fist, doesn’t it?

Him: yes…

Me: say it.

Him: I have a small dick.

Me: again. Like you mean it.

Him: I have a small dick. It’s 3.5 inches. not average. Smaller than yours by a lot.

Me: good boy. now send me a video of you stroking it. Use two fingers, like I did.

He didn’t respond for a while. I thought he might send one. Then:

Him: sorry. I think I need to stop.

And that was it. No more messages. No more pics. Just silence.

It’s a shame, honestly. He was nice, and he could suck cock like a pro. But the realization hit him hard, and I don’t think he was ready to keep playing after the tape measure came out. Maybe he’ll come back. Maybe he won’t. If he does, I’ll be ready with the ruler—and maybe without it.

 

The End.

 

Leave a Reply

Translate »