SPH-THEMED EROTICA STORIES

Amy wasn’t my first kiss. She wasn’t my first crush. But she was the first girl I ever had sex with, and she made damn sure I’d never forget the experience — though not for the reasons you might be hoping.

I was twenty when we started dating. She was the same age, but lightyears ahead of me in experience. I’d later find out the exact number — seven guys before me. Seven. I’d been with zero. That gap alone would’ve been enough to mess with my head, but it turned out to be the least of my problems.

She was cute. Brown hair that fell past her shoulders, a sharp smile, and this way of looking at you that made you feel like she was reading your thoughts. I was smitten immediately. The fact that she was interested in me at all felt like winning a lottery I didn’t even buy a ticket for.

We’d been together about three weeks before we had sex for the first time. I remember being nervous — not just performance anxiety, but that specific dread of being seen, of being known. I’d been aware for a long time that I wasn’t exactly packing heat. It’s not something you talk about with other guys, so I’d quietly carried that uncertainty through my teens, hoping maybe I was a late bloomer, hoping maybe it didn’t matter as much as I feared.

When the moment finally came, she didn’t laugh. She didn’t gasp. She didn’t say anything cruel. She just… carried on. We had sex, and it was fine. Not earth-shattering, not terrible. Just fine. She seemed to enjoy herself well enough, or at least she was good at making me think she did. I took that as a win.

For the first month or so, things felt normal. We’d fuck a few times a week, go out, hang out with our shared friend group. I was riding the high of finally having a girlfriend, finally having sex, finally feeling like a normal guy.

Then came the Denny’s morning.

—

It was a Saturday. We’d stayed at her place the night before and woke up hungry, so we drove to the Denny’s near her apartment. It was one of those lazy mornings where neither of us was in a rush — just coffee and pancakes and the kind of wandering conversation couples have when they’re still figuring each other out.

The restaurant was pretty empty for that time of day. A few tables occupied, a couple of tired-looking parents with kids, an older man reading a newspaper near the window. Then the door opened, and this guy walked in.

He was huge. Not fat — just big. Tall, broad shoulders, thick arms straining against his T-shirt. He looked like he played college football or maybe did construction for a living. He had that effortless mass that some guys just carry. Amy’s eyes tracked him the moment he stepped through the door.

She didn’t even try to be subtle about it. Her head turned, her gaze following him as he walked past our booth to sit at the counter. She watched him sit down, watched him pick up a menu, watched him for a beat longer than necessary.

I noticed. Obviously.

She caught me noticing and let out a little laugh, not even guilty about it. “Sorry,” she said, stirring her coffee. “You can’t help but look sometimes.”

I didn’t say anything right away. I think I made some weak joke about how she should pick her jaw up off the table. She grinned.

Then she said something that stuck with me for years.

“You know what’s wild?” She leaned forward on her elbows. “You can never tell how big a guy is just by looking at him. Like, ever.”

I blinked. “What do you mean?”

She took a sip of her coffee, completely casual, like we were discussing the weather. “I mean exactly that. Guys who look like they’d be huge sometimes aren’t. And guys who look like nothing sometimes… are.”

She said it with this matter-of-fact ease that told me this wasn’t a theoretical observation. This was data. Collected. Personal.

My stomach did something weird. Not a full drop yet — more like a slow tilt. I should’ve changed the subject. I didn’t.

“Like who?”

She set her cup down and tilted her head, thinking. “Okay, well — you know Marcus? That guy I dated sophomore year?”

I didn’t know Marcus. I didn’t know any of her exes by name yet. But I nodded as I did.

“He was tall. Like six-two, six-three. Built. Played basketball. You’d assume he’d be packing, right?” She paused. “He was maybe average. Like, totally average. Not small, but nothing special. Honestly kind of a letdown given how he looked.”

She laughed a little at the memory. I forced a smile.

“Then there was this other guy, Tyler. Short guy. Like five-seven, skinny, kind of nerdy-looking. I hooked up with him at a party once and—” She raised her eyebrows. “Holy shit. I was not expecting that.”

I waited. She didn’t make me wait long.

“He was easily the biggest I’d ever seen. Like, I didn’t even know they came that big. I couldn’t even—” She stopped herself, laughing again. “Let’s just say it was a lot to handle.”

My throat felt dry. I reached for my water glass.

“And then there was my last boyfriend,” she continued, not picking up on my discomfort — or maybe just not caring. “Derek.”

Derek. Her boyfriend of a year. The one before me. I’d heard bits and pieces about him. They’d broken up a few months before we met. She’d described the relationship as “serious but not going anywhere.”

“What about him?” My voice came out flatter than I intended.

She looked at me with this expression — not cruel, not mocking, just… honest. Almost clinical.

“Derek was short. Shorter than me, actually. I’m five-five; he was maybe five-six on a good day. Skinny. Like, really skinny. You’d look at him and think, there’s no way this guy has anything going on down there.”

She let the silence hang for a second.

“He was huge. Like, genuinely huge. I don’t know exactly how big because I never measured, but it was—” She held her hands apart, and the gap between them made my chest tighten. “I mean, it was enormous. Thick, too. The first time we had sex, I actually thought he wasn’t going to fit.”

She said this with a kind of fond nostalgia, as if she were reminiscing about a favorite vacation spot.

“Sex with him was… different. Like, I could feel him everywhere. He didn’t even have to try that hard. Just being that big meant things happened that don’t usually happen, you know?”

I didn’t know. I had no frame of reference for what she was describing. I’d been inside her maybe two dozen times by then, and I’d never once felt like I was making anything happen.

I was staring at my pancakes. They’d gone cold.

“And then there’s you.”

Three words. She said them so simply, so lightly, like she was just completing a list. But the way she trailed off after — not finishing the sentence, not adding a descriptor, not saying “and you’re great too” or “and you’re perfect for me” — the absence said everything.

I looked up. She was already reaching for her phone, checking something, completely unaware — or maybe fully aware — of what she’d just done.

“What about me?” I asked. My voice was quieter than I wanted it to be.

She glanced up from her phone. “Hmm?”

“You said, ‘and then there’s you.’ What does that mean?”

She looked at me for a second like she was deciding whether to be honest. Then she shrugged. “I mean… you know what you’re working with.”

I did know. That was the problem. I knew exactly what I was working with, and now I knew where it ranked on her personal scoreboard.

“Is it… I mean, does it matter to you?”

She gave me this look — half-sympathetic, half-amused. “It’s not the only thing that matters. But yeah, it matters. It’s different. Sex with you is different than it was with some of those other guys.”

“Different how?”

She sighed as if I were asking her to explain something obvious. “Different like… I can tell you’re trying really hard, and that’s sweet. But physically, it’s just not the same. Like, with Derek, I could feel him deep, you know? He’d hit spots I didn’t even know I had. With you, it’s more like…” She searched for the word. “Gentle. Which is nice sometimes.”

Gentle. She’d called my dick gentle. I wanted to disappear into the vinyl booth.

I didn’t say much for the rest of breakfast. She noticed, asked if I was okay, and I said I was fine. I paid the check. We left. I dropped her off at her place and drove home in silence, sitting with the new, heavy knowledge that my girlfriend had a ranking system, and I was at the bottom of it.

—

I didn’t break up with her. I should have. In hindsight, that conversation alone should’ve been enough. But I was twenty, she was my first everything, and the thought of losing her was worse than the slow erosion of my self-esteem.

So I stayed. And I tried harder. I read articles. I tried different positions. I went down on her more, partly because I wanted to make up for what I lacked, and partly because it meant less time with the part of me that had been measured and found wanting.

She never complained directly. But she’d make comments—little things. Like if we were watching a movie and a sex scene came on, she’d say something about the guy. Or if we were out somewhere and she saw a guy she found attractive, she’d be less careful about hiding it than she’d been before Denny’s. Like that conversation had opened a door she didn’t bother closing again.

I started noticing things I hadn’t noticed before. The way she’d sometimes shift positions during sex — not to get more comfortable, but to try to create friction I wasn’t providing. The way she’d sometimes go quiet in the middle of it, her mind clearly somewhere else. The way she’d sometimes finish herself off with her hand after I’d already finished, quick and efficient, like she was topping off a tank I’d only managed to fill halfway.

I noticed all of it. And I said nothing.

—

The party happened about six weeks into our relationship. It was at a friend’s house — one of those crowded, loud, college-town parties where everyone knows everyone and the drinks are strong and free.

Our friend group was tight. Maybe twelve, fifteen people who hung out regularly. A mix of guys and girls. We’d all been through each other’s drama, hookups, breakups, and gossip. It was the kind of group where everyone eventually knew everyone’s business.

I got drunk. Way too drunk, way too fast. I’d been drinking to cope with the low-grade anxiety that had been living in my chest since the Denny’s conversation, and that night, I overdid it. I remember being at the party, talking to people, laughing. Then I remember the room spinning. Then I remember sitting on a couch. Then I remember nothing.

I passed out in a bedroom upstairs. Someone — I don’t know who — put me on my side and closed the door. I was out cold.

What happened next, I pieced together from multiple sources over the following days.

The party continued without me. People kept drinking. The crowd thinned out as it got later, until it was just our core group sitting around the living room — maybe ten people, passing around drinks and cigarettes, talking the way people talk at two in the morning when their filters are gone.

The conversation drifted to sex. It always does at that hour. Someone made a joke about a guy one of the girls had hooked up with, and that opened the floodgates. The girls started trading stories. Who was good. Who was bad. Who was surprising. Who was disappointing.

And then someone asked the question. I don’t know who. Maybe one of the guys trying to get intel on a girl he liked. Maybe one of the girls feeling bold. But someone asked about me.

“How’s things with you and [me]?”

Amy was drunk. Not as drunk as I’d been, but drunk enough. And when Amy was drunk, she got honest. Brutally, carelessly honest.

She laughed. Not a mean laugh — more like an exasperated one. “Honestly? He’s really sweet. Like, really sweet. But…”

“But what?”

She took a drink. Set it down. Looked around the room at faces she knew well, people she saw every week, people who would look me in the eye the next day knowing what she was about to say.

“He’s got a small dick.”

Someone — probably one of the guys — made a sound: a half-laugh, half-wince.

“Like how small?” someone asked.

She held up her fingers. Not far apart. “Like four inches. Maybe four inches hard.”

The room went quiet for a second. Then someone — I still don’t know who — let out a laugh they couldn’t hold back. And then the room loosened up again, and the questions came faster.

“Seriously?”

“Four inches? Like, fully hard?”

“Have you measured it?”

“I haven’t measured it, but I’ve seen enough to know. It’s small.”

“And does it… I mean, does it work? Like, are you satisfied?”

She paused. That pause killed me, even though I wasn’t there to hear it. Even hearing about it secondhand weeks later, that pause made me want to put my fist through a wall.

“It works,” she said carefully. “I mean, he tries really hard. He goes down on me a lot, which is nice. But honestly? Yeah, it kinda sucks. Like, there’s only so much you can do with that. I can barely feel it sometimes. And I know that sounds awful, but you asked.”

She’d said it. Out loud. To our entire friend group. She’d told everyone — every guy I’d grab a beer with, every girl I’d make small talk with — that I had a four-inch dick and that sex with me was underwhelming.

I found out about this conversation not from Amy, but from the friend who’d been sitting closest to her. He told me two days later, almost apologetically, as if he were delivering a eulogy. “Dude, she was talking about your… situation. At the party. After you passed out, everyone heard.”

I felt the blood leave my face. “What did she say?”

He told me. All of it. The four inches. The “kinda sucks.” The finger measurement. The quiet, sympathetic looks from the other girls. The way one of the guys had said “damn, dude” and shaken his head.

I sat with that for a long time.

—

But the night wasn’t over. While I was unconscious upstairs, the party continued, and one of my so-called friends — let’s call him Ryan — saw an opportunity.

Ryan was one of those guys who was always a little too friendly with everyone’s girlfriends. Not overtly — he was smart about it. He’d frame it as just being social, just being nice. But you could see the way he operated if you paid attention. He’d find the crack in a relationship and slide into it.

That night, the crack was four inches wide.

After Amy’s confession, Ryan zeroed in on her. He didn’t do it obviously — he wasn’t stupid. But he moved closer to her on the couch. Started talking to her one-on-one. Asked her about the relationship. Was she happy? Did she feel fulfilled? Made little comments about how she deserved better, how a girl like her shouldn’t have to settle.

He was listening to her complain about me and nodding along like a therapist, and the whole time he was building a case for himself.

I don’t know the exact sequence of events. I don’t know if they kissed in the living room or waited until people filtered out. I don’t know what he said to get her upstairs — or if they even went upstairs, or if they just went to his car, or if they stayed on that couch after everyone else had left or passed out.

What I know is that they fucked. That night. At the same time, I was asleep one room away.

Ryan told me himself. The next morning. He came up to me while I was sitting on the kitchen counter nursing a hangover and trying to remember how I’d gotten upstairs, and he told me with this look on his face that I still can’t fully describe. Not quite guilt. Not quite pride. Something in between.

“Hey man, I need to tell you something.”

“What?”

“I hooked up with Amy last night.”

I stared at him. My hangover made everything feel like it was happening underwater. “What are you talking about?”

“After you passed out. We were talking, and one thing led to another, and… yeah.”

I kept staring at him and waiting for the punchline. Waiting for him to say he was joking.

He wasn’t joking.

“How?” I asked, which was a stupid question, but it# The Moment Everything Changed

Part I: Denny’s

I still remember the smell of that Denny’s. Stale coffee and maple syrup baked into the vinyl booths, the fluorescent lights humming just loud enough to notice if you weren’t talking. Amy and I had gotten a booth by the window. It was a Saturday morning, maybe eleven o’clock. She was picking at a Grand Slam, and I was working through a plate of hash browns. We’d been together about two months at that point, and we’d been fucking for about a month.

Amy was my first. I was not hers. Not even close.

 

 

She’d told me early on, matter-of-factly, that she’d been with seven guys before me. She said it the way someone might tell you how many states they’ve visited: no shame, no bragging, just information. I was twenty-one, and she was twenty-three, and at the time I thought that made her worldly. I thought I was lucky to be with someone who knew what she was doing. And in a lot of ways, I was. She taught me things. She was patient with me at first. She showed me where to put my hands, how to use my mouth, how to pace myself instead of jackhammering like a porn star having a seizure.

But there was always this quiet understanding between us that she had a frame of reference and I didn’t. Every time we had sex, she was comparing me to seven other men, whether she meant to or not. And I knew it even if I didn’t want to admit it to myself.

So we’re sitting at Denny’s, and the door opens, and this guy walks in. He was huge. Not fat, just big. Tall, broad shoulders, thick neck. Looked like he played college football, worked construction, or both. He was with a woman who was about half his size. Amy didn’t even try to be subtle. Her eyes tracked him across the restaurant as the hostess seated him on the other side of the room.

I noticed. Of course I noticed. You notice when your girlfriend is staring at another man.

“What?” she said, catching my expression.

“Nothing.”

“You saw me looking.”

“Yeah.”

She shrugged. “He’s hot. I can look.” Then she smiled and stabbed a piece of pancake with her fork. “Anyway, you can never tell how hung a guy is just by looking at him.”

I didn’t say anything at first. I think I laughed a little, the way you do when you’re not sure if something is funny or if you should be uncomfortable. “What do you mean?”

“I mean exactly what I said. You can’t tell. Some big guys are small. Some small guys are big. It’s like a lottery.” She chewed, swallowed, took a sip of her orange juice. “Like, you know how they say big hands, big feet, big dick? Total myth.”

“Is it?”

“Mmhm. One hundred percent myth.” She set down her fork and looked at me across the table. “You want examples?”

I should have said no. I should have changed the subject. But I was twenty-one and stupid, and I thought I wanted to know. I thought being the kind of boyfriend who could handle hearing about his girlfriend’s past made me mature. Secure. Confident.

“Yeah, sure,” I said.

“Okay.” She held up a finger. “Guy number one. My freshman year. Tall guy. Basketball player. Like six-four, six-five. Hands like dinner plates. And he had maybe the smallest dick I’ve ever seen. Like, I didn’t even know they came that small on someone that big.” She held up her pinky finger and wiggled it, then laughed. “I felt bad for him. He was really self-conscious about it.”

She held up a second finger. “Guy number two. Average height, average build. Nothing special. Maybe five-nine. And he was pretty big. Like, decent. Nothing crazy, but definitely above average. Surprised me.”

Third finger. “Guy number three was kind of small. Five-six, skinny. And he was okay. Middle of the road. Maybe a little under average.”

She went through a few more. Some of them I remember clearly, some of them blurred together. She talked about them the way you’d talk about restaurants you’ve been to. This one was good, that one was disappointing, this one was memorable for the wrong reasons. She described one guy who was thick but short. Another who was long but thin. One who curved to the left so much that she had to adjust her position to make it work.

Then she got to her last boyfriend—the one before me.

“Okay, so,” she said, and her tone shifted. Not dramatically, but enough. There was something warmer in it. More respectful, maybe. “My last boyfriend. We were together for a year.”

“I remember,” I said.

“Yeah. So he was short. Like, five-six. Skinny. You’d look at him and think nothing of it. He wore glasses. He was kind of nerdy. Quiet. You would never in a million years guess—” She stopped and shook her head, almost laughing. “He had the biggest cock I’ve ever seen.”

I felt something drop in my stomach, like missing a step on a staircase.

“How big?” I asked. My voice sounded normal. Casual. Inside, I was already starting to feel something I couldn’t name yet.

“I don’t know exactly. I never measured. But it was—” She held her hands apart, maybe eight or nine inches, and then laughed and brought them closer together. “Okay, maybe not that big. But it was big. Like, I had to use both hands. Like, it took me a while to take it all. The first time we had sex, I couldn’t. I literally couldn’t. We had to work up to it.”

She said this with a kind of fondness that made it worse. Not nostalgia exactly, but something close to it. The way you talk about a really good meal you had on vacation.

“And he knew how to use it,” she added. “That’s the other thing. Having a big dick doesn’t mean anything if you don’t know what to do with it. But he did.”

I nodded. I picked up my fork and moved a piece of hash brown around my plate. I wasn’t hungry anymore.

Then she looked at me. And there was this pause. This fraction of a second where I could see her make a decision. Whether to say it or not. She said it.

“And then there’s you.”

She said it with a little smile. Not cruel, not mocking. Almost affectionate. Like she was telling me something we both already knew and it was okay. Like it was just a fact. Like saying “and then there’s you” was the same as saying “and then there’s Tuesday.”

I’m six-foot-one. I played sports in high school. I’m not a small guy. I’ve been told I have a commanding presence. People look up to me, literally. And I have a small penis.

Four inches. Fully erect. I know because I measured it later that night in my bathroom with a ruler I borrowed from my roommate’s desk, standing over the toilet with the door locked, trying to get hard while my hands were shaking. Four inches. Maybe four and a quarter if I pressed the ruler in, which I did, because I needed every fraction I could get.

Amy didn’t say “small.” She didn’t say “tiny.” She just said, “and then there’s you,” and then she moved on to something else, maybe the pancakes, maybe the football game later that day. I don’t remember because I wasn’t there anymore. I was somewhere inside my own head, standing in front of a ruler, doing math. Seven guys. Seven guys before me. And at least one of them had a cock so big she couldn’t take it all at first. And then there’s me.

I didn’t say anything. I smiled and nodded and finished my hash browns and paid the check and drove her home, and we had sex that afternoon, and I tried harder than I’d ever tried. I went down on her for a long time. I used my fingers. I did everything she’d taught me. And when I finally pushed inside her, I couldn’t stop thinking about whether she could feel me. Whether she was thinking about him. Whether she was thinking about any of them.

She made the right sounds. She always made the right sounds. But after that morning at Denny’s, every sound she made sounded like charity to me.

—

Part II: The Party

It was a few weeks later. Maybe a month. The Denny’s conversation had settled into my brain like a splinter, the kind that works its way deeper the more you poke at it. I hadn’t said anything to Amy about it. I hadn’t said anything to anyone. But I was different. Quieter in bed. More hesitant. I’d catch myself watching her face during sex, looking for signs of disappointment, signs of boredom. I started going down on her more, partly because I wanted her to enjoy herself, partly because I was afraid of the moment when I’d be inside her, and she’d be thinking about someone else.

The party was at Derek’s house. Derek was a friend of mine from work. He threw parties every few weeks, and our whole friend group would show up. There were maybe fifteen or twenty of us. Beer pong in the kitchen, music in the living room, people smoking on the back porch. The usual.

Amy was there with me. So were most of our friends. And so was Marcus.

Marcus was an asshole. I say that with the benefit of hindsight, but honestly, I probably knew it at the time too. He was one of those guys who was friends with everyone but loyal to no one. Good-looking in a way that made other guys uncomfortable. Charming when he wanted to be. He had this way of talking to women that made them feel like they were the only person in the room, and he used it constantly. He’d been a friend of mine for a couple of years, but even I knew not to trust him with anything important.

I started drinking early. Too early. Too much. I was doing shots with some of the guys, then beer, then more shots. I remember being in the kitchen playing beer pong with Derek and missing every shot. I remember Amy laughing at me from the doorway. I remember Marcus standing near her, leaning against the wall, watching.

The next thing I remember clearly is waking up on the floor of Derek’s spare bedroom with a jacket over me and a splitting headache. But I’m getting ahead of myself.

Before I passed out, apparently, the party thinned out. The beer pong table got folded up. People settled into clusters. Some people left. The remaining group ended up in the living room, sitting on couches, chairs, and the floor, passing around drinks and talking. Amy was there. Marcus was there. Our friends were there. I was still technically conscious at this point, slumped on the couch, but barely. I was in that gray zone where you can hear things but can’t respond, where the room spins if you open your eyes.

I don’t remember the conversation. I’m piecing this together from what I was told over the next few days by multiple people. Some of it came from Amy herself, in fragments. Some of it came from friends who were there. Some of it came from Marcus, who told me with a grin.

The conversation turned to sex. It always does at parties, eventually. Someone made a joke. Someone else topped it. Then someone asked a question about penis size, and the room split along gender lines. The guys got defensive. The girls got honest.

One of the girls, I think it was Lisa, started it. She said something about her boyfriend being “perfectly adequate,” and everyone laughed. Then someone asked what “adequate” meant, and Lisa held up her fingers about five inches apart, and the room erupted. Guys groaning, girls giggling. Someone else asked who the biggest any of them had been with was, and the stories started flowing.

One girl talked about a guy she’d been with in college who was so big she’d been sore for two days. Another said her current boyfriend was the biggest she’d had. Another said size didn’t matter that much, which got eye rolls from every other woman in the room.

Then someone turned to Amy. I think it was Lisa. “What about you, Amy? You’ve been around.”

Amy laughed. “I’ve had my share.”

“So who’s the biggest?”

She talked about her ex. The short, skinny nerd with the huge cock. She described it again, the same way she had at Denny’s, but this time with an audience. She held her hands apart. She talked about how she couldn’t take it all at first. She talked about how it felt going deep. The room was riveted. The guys were shifting in their seats. The girls were leaning forward.

Then Lisa said, “So what about your current guy?” And she pointed at me, slumped on the couch.

The room went quiet for a second. Then Amy looked at me, looked back at the group, and shrugged.

“He’s four inches.”

She said it plainly. No drama. No hesitation. Just a number, delivered like a weather report.

Someone laughed. I think it was Marcus. Then someone else. Then the room kind of collectively exhaled and moved on, because what else do you do when someone drops a bomb like that at a party?

But Amy wasn’t done. She added, “It’s okay. I mean, it’s not great. It kind of sucks, honestly. Like, I don’t really feel that much. He tries; he goes down on me a lot, which is nice. But when we’re actually doing it, it’s just… I don’t know. It’s fine.”

“It’s fine.” She said it twice, and both times it landed harder than if she’d said it was terrible. “Fine” is the word you use when you don’t want to be cruel but you also can’t bring yourself to lie. “Fine” is what you say about a meal you wouldn’t order again.

I was on the couch. I heard it. I’m not sure how much I processed in the moment, but I heard it. I heard my girlfriend tell a room full of our friends that I have a four-inch penis and that sex with me kind of sucks. I heard the laughter. I heard the silence after. I heard someone change the subject.

I don’t remember passing out. I just remember being awake, and then not.

—

Part III: Marcus

I woke up on the floor of the spare bedroom around seven in the morning. My mouth tasted like an ashtray. My head felt like someone had filled it with wet concrete. I sat up, and the room tilted. I found my phone. It was dead. I found my shoes. I stumbled out into the hallway.

The house was quiet. Most people had left. A few were sleeping in various positions around the living room. Derek was in the kitchen making coffee. He looked at me and said, “Rough night?”

“Yeah.”

I sat at the kitchen table and drank water. I asked where Amy was. Derek said he thought she’d left early. I nodded. I asked if anyone had seen my phone charger. He said to check the living room.

Marcus came downstairs about twenty minutes later. He lived nearby and had often crashed at Derek’s place. He came into the kitchen, poured himself coffee, sat across from me, and grinned.

That grin. I’ll never forget it. It was the grin of someone who knows something you don’t. The grin of someone who has done something and can’t wait to tell you about it, not because it’s important, but because it’s yours and he took it.

“Dude,” he said. “Crazy night.”

“Yeah?”

“Yeah.” He sipped his coffee. “So after you passed out, your girl was hanging out with everyone, and we got to talking, and one thing led to another.”

My stomach dropped. I knew what was coming. I think I knew before he said it. Maybe I’d known since I saw him leaning against the wall next to her earlier in the evening.

“What are you talking about?”

“I hooked up with Amy last night.”

The words landed like stones dropped into still water. I stared at him. He stared back. He was still grinning. Not a big grin, just a slight one. The kind that says, “What are you going to do about it?”

“What?”

“Yeah, man. After you passed out, she was hanging around, we were talking, and she was—she was upset. She was venting about stuff. About you guys. About the sex thing. She was saying how she loves you, but it’s frustrating, and I was just being a good listener, and one thing led to another.”

“Where?”

“In the spare bedroom.”

“The spare bedroom.” The room I’d been sleeping in. I’d been on the floor. Maybe they’d been on the bed three feet away. Maybe she’d looked at me while he was inside her. Maybe she hadn’t. Maybe she hadn’t thought about me at all.

“She came on to me,” Marcus said. “I want you to know that. She came on to me. I didn’t force anything.”

I didn’t say anything. I sat there. I drank my water. I looked at the table.

“She was really into it,” he added. And then, after a pause: “She was really into it.”

I knew what he meant. He wasn’t just saying she was enthusiastic. He was telling me something else. Something about the difference. Something about what it felt like to fuck someone who could actually feel it. He was telling me that she’d been with a real man, a man who could fill her up, and that she’d responded the way she’d never responded to me.

I didn’t punch him. I didn’t yell. I didn’t do anything. I sat at that kitchen table, drank water, and felt something break inside me. Not dramatically. Not like glass shattering. More like a crack in a dam. Small. Almost invisible. But once it’s there, the water finds it. And the water never stops.

I got up. I found my phone charger. I called Amy. She answered on the third ring.

“We need to talk,” I said.

“I know,” she said.

—

Part IV: The Last Month

We talked. She cried. She apologized. She said it was a mistake. She said she was drunk. She said she didn’t mean what she said at the party. She said Marcus came on to her, and she was weak, confused, and frustrated.

I asked her if she’d said those things about me. About my size. About the sex. She admitted she had. She said she didn’t mean for me to hear. She said she was just talking with friends and it came out.

“It came out,” I repeated.

“I’m sorry.”

“Did you fuck him in the same room I was sleeping in?”

Silence.

“Amy.”

“Yes. But you were passed out. You didn’t—”

“Was he bigger than me?”

I don’t know why I asked. I don’t know what I was hoping to hear. Maybe I wanted her to lie. Maybe I wanted her to say it didn’t matter. Maybe I wanted her to say something that would make it okay.

She didn’t say anything for a long time. Then she said, “Yes.”

I hung up.

We broke up a month later. Not immediately, because I was weak and confused and I didn’t want to be alone. I didn’t want to be the guy who got cheated on and then dumped. I wanted to fix it. I wanted to prove something. I wanted to be the boyfriend who was so good in other ways that it didn’t matter that I was small.

But it mattered. It always mattered. Every time we had sex, I could feel it. I could feel her tolerating me. I could feel her patience, which was worse than her impatience would have been. I went down on her until my jaw ached. I used my fingers. I bought a toy. I tried everything. And every time I was inside her, I could feel the space. The space that I couldn’t fill. The space that Marcus had filled. The space that her ex had filled. The space that seven guys before me had filled.

She’d moan, and I’d think: Is that real? Is that for me? Or is that what she sounds like when she’s actually enjoying it, with someone who can actually reach the places I can’t?

One night, about three weeks before we broke up, she was on top of me, and she was grinding, and I slipped out. She reached down to put me back in, and I watched her hand wrap around my cock, her fingers overlapping, and I saw it. I saw how small I looked in her hand. I saw her face, focused, slightly annoyed, trying to get me back inside her. And I went soft, just like that. I couldn’t get it back.

She rolled off. She didn’t say anything. She lay next to me and stared at the ceiling. I stared at the ceiling. Neither of us said anything for a long time.

We broke up on a Tuesday. She came over to my apartment. We sat on the couch. She said she didn’t think this was working. I agreed. She said she was sorry. I said I was sorry. She left.

Two weeks later, I saw her Facebook status change. She was in a relationship with Marcus.

I stared at the screen for a long time. Then I closed my laptop, sat in my apartment, and thought about Denny’s. About the way she’d held her hands apart when she talked about her ex. About the way she’d said “and then there’s you.” About the way she’d told a room full of people that I was four inches and it kind of sucked. About the way Marcus had grinned at me across the kitchen table.

I thought about how I’d never measured myself before that breakfast. I’d never thought about it. I’d known I wasn’t huge, but I didn’t know I was small. I didn’t know there was a word for what I was. I didn’t know it was something that could be discussed at parties, announced like a fact, used as a reason to cheat.

That’s where it started. Right there. At a Denny’s on a Saturday morning, over pancakes and hash browns, with a sentence that took two seconds to say and a lifetime to forget.

And then there’s you.

I’ve never been the same since.

 

The End.

*The opinions/views expressed in this story (and in any comments) are those of the author and do not represent this site. We support freedom of speech. This story has been submitted directly to this website for publication. Thanks for your submission.