Seat Down
An SPH Experience by old_dog007.
Our house isn’t small, but it’s not exactly designed for four adults either. Three bedrooms, one bathroom. That single bathroom became the bane of my existence almost immediately.
I grew up with brothers. I learned the toilet seat dance early—put it up, do your business, put it back down. It was muscle memory by the time I got married. Linda never had to say a word about it in thirty-two years of marriage because I just… did it. Automatic. Considerate.
It seems Sil had different training.
In the first week, Linda nearly broke her hip, stumbling into the bowl in the middle of the night. She came back to bed cursing under her breath, and I lay there pretending to be asleep because I didn’t want to deal with it. The second week, I was the one who almost fell in. The third week, we both started checking before we sat down, like the bathroom had become a minefield and we were navigating it blind.
“Talk to him,” Linda said one morning, applying her mascara while I shaved.
“It’s his house too.”
“It’s our house. He’s a guest.”
“He’s family.”
“Family can put the fucking seat down.”
I didn’t talk to him. I’m not good at confrontation, never have been. Instead, I developed this whole routine—wake up, shuffle to the bathroom, check the seat, flip it down if necessary, pee, flush, wash hands, go back to bed. Most mornings, it was up. Most mornings, I didn’t think much about it beyond a mild annoyance.
The thing is, I do sit down to pee. Not always, but often. Especially in the middle of the night when I’m half-asleep and don’t want to turn on the light and wake everyone up. Especially when Linda’s already awake, and I don’t want to make noise. Especially when I just… don’t feel like standing.
It’s not just about size. That’s what I tell myself, anyway. It’s about convenience. Comfort. Not having to aim at three in the morning when my eyes won’t even focus.
But yeah. The size thing is part of it.
I’m small. I’ve always been small. Linda’s known since our first time together when we were nineteen, and she’s never made me feel bad about it. Not once in three decades. She’s the type of woman who genuinely doesn’t care—she’s told me that, and I believe her. Sex has always been good between us, and if there were times I wondered if she was settling, if she secretly wished for more, she never showed it.
That’s probably why what happened caught me so off guard.
It was a Sunday evening in late August, about two months into their stay. We were all crammed into the living room—me in the recliner, Linda on the couch with her feet tucked under her, Brittany in the other recliner scrolling through her phone, and Sil sprawled on the floor in front of the TV playing something on the Xbox. The windows were open, and you could hear the neighbors’ kids playing outside, that distant shrieking laughter that makes summer evenings feel like summer evenings.
“I made a roast,” Linda said, scrolling through her own phone. “Anyone hungry?”
“Starving,” Brittany said without looking up.
Sil paused his game. “I could eat.”
We migrated to the kitchen, the four of us squeezing around a table meant for three. Linda carved the meat, Brittany passed plates, Sil made jokes about needing to marry a woman who could cook like her mother. Normal family dinner stuff. Comfortable. Easy.
I was reaching for the potatoes when Linda cleared her throat.
“So,” she said, in that voice that meant she’d been thinking about something for a while. “Can we talk about the bathroom situation?”
My hand froze.
“What about it?” Brittany asked.
“The seat. It’s always up. Every single time Sil uses it, it’s up. And one of these days, someone’s going to forget to check and end up in the emergency room.”
Sil shrugged, not looking particularly bothered. “Force of habit. I’ll try to remember.”
“You’ve been trying for two months,” Linda said, her tone light but pointed.
“I’ll try harder.”
“It’s not that hard,” Brittany chimed in. “Just put it down when you’re done.”
“I said I’d try.”
Linda sighed and turned to me. “And you—you’re no help at all. You never put it up, but you never complain about it being up either.”
I blinked. “I… what?”
“The seat. You never leave it up. Ever. In thirty-two years of marriage, I don’t think I’ve seen the seat up once after you’ve used that bathroom.”
I felt the heat start to creep up my neck. “I just… don’t.”
“But you also never complain when Sil leaves it up. You just put it down and move on.”
“I check before I sit.”
“Every time?”
“Yes?”
She tilted her head, studying me. “You know, I used to think you were just being considerate. Leaving the seat down because you knew I preferred it. But that’s not it, is it?”
My mouth opened, but nothing came out.
“You sit down to pee,” Linda said, and it wasn’t a question.
The room went quiet. Even Sil paused with his fork halfway to his mouth.
“I… sometimes. Not always.”
“Most of the time,” Linda corrected. “I can hear you in the morning. No standing sound. Just sitting.”
“I don’t—”
“It’s because you’re so small,” she said, and her voice was matter-of-fact, not cruel, just… observational. “You have to sit down. Standing would make a mess.”
The silence that followed was the loudest thing I’d ever heard.
Brittany made a sound—half gasp, half laugh. Sil’s fork clattered against his plate. My face was on fire, and I couldn’t look at any of them, so I stared at the roast like it held the secrets of the universe.
“Dad,” Brittany said, and then she was laughing, full-body laughing, the kind of laugh that makes your eyes water. “Oh, my God. Dad sits down to pee because he’s small.”
“I didn’t—” I started, but what was I going to say? I didn’t sit down? Wasn’t I small? Both of those things were lies, and everyone in the room knew it.
“That’s why you never leave the seat up,” Linda continued, and there was something almost playful in her tone now, as if she were figuring out a puzzle she’d been working on for decades. “You don’t need it up. You sit down every time because you have to.”
“I don’t have to—”
“Sweetheart, it’s okay.” She patted my hand, and the gesture was somehow worse than if she’d mocked me. “I’ve seen it. I’ve seen it for thirty-two years. You have nothing to work with standing up. Sitting is just… practical.”
Brittany was wheezing. Sil had his hand over his mouth, shoulders shaking. Even Linda was smiling now, this small, knowing smile that made my stomach flip in a way I didn’t want to examine.
“This is the best day of my life,” Brittany managed. “I’m texting Jess.”
“Please don’t.”
“She needs to know her grandfather sits down to pee.”
“I’m fifty-three years old, I don’t need—”
“Because he’s small,” Brittany added, like she couldn’t help herself. “Like, medically small. Dad, are you technically considered to have a micropenis? Is that something you’ve ever looked into?”
“Brittany!”
“What? It’s a real medical condition. There’s support groups.”
“I don’t have a—” I stopped. Took a breath. “I’m not having this conversation.”
“Aw, Dad’s embarrassed.” Brittany was grinning, and she looked so much like her mother in that moment—same dark eyes, same tilt to her head. “Don’t worry, we won’t tell anyone.”
“You’re literally texting someone right now.”
“Jess doesn’t count.”
Sil finally spoke up, his voice strained from holding back laughter. “Hey man, it’s cool. My uncle’s the same way. He sits down too. We went on a fishing trip once, and I thought something was wrong with him, but nope. Just… equipment issues.”
“Equipment issues,” I repeated flatly.
“You know what I mean.”
“I really don’t.”
Linda squeezed my hand. “Honey, it’s fine. Really. No one here cares about the size of your penis. We’re just… having a conversation.”
“A conversation about my penis.”
“Well, it came up naturally.”
“It came up because you brought it up.”
“I was just explaining why you never leave the seat up.” She smiled again, and there was something in it that made my insides twist. “I think it’s sweet, actually. You’ve been protecting my furniture from pee splatter for three decades because you’re too small to aim.”
“I can aim.”
“Can you?”
“Yes?”
“Then why do you sit?”
The question hung in the air. I didn’t have an answer that didn’t involve admitting something I didn’t want to admit in front of my daughter and son-in-law.
“That’s what I thought,” Linda said gently. “It’s okay. Really. I married you knowing exactly what you were working with, and I’ve never been disappointed.”
“Mom,” Brittany said, still laughing. “Too much information.”
“You brought up micropenises first.”
“Fair point.”
I sat there, face burning, stomach doing something complicated, and tried to figure out how my life had come to this. One minute we were eating roast, and the next my wife was discussing my penis size at the dinner table like it was the weather.
“Can we please talk about something else?” I managed.
“Sure,” Linda said easily. “Sil, how’s work?”
The conversation shifted. Sil started talking about his construction job, and Brittany asked about benefits, and Linda nodded along as if nothing had happened, like she hadn’t just told our daughter and her husband that I was too small to pee standing up.
I excused myself early. Went to the bathroom—checked the seat first, found it up, flipped it down, sat, and tried not to think about how everyone in the house now knew exactly why I did it.
Later that night, in bed, Linda rolled over and put her hand on my chest.
“You okay?” she asked.
“Fine.”
“You seemed upset at dinner.”
“I wasn’t upset. I was humiliated.”
“There’s a difference?”
I turned to look at her. “Did you have to say all that? In front of them?”
“Would you rather I said it in private?”
“I’d rather you didn’t say it at all.”
She was quiet for a moment. Then: “I didn’t think it was a secret.”
“It wasn’t a secret, but it wasn’t… dinner conversation.”
“Honey, I’ve known for thirty-two years. Brittany’s been living here for two months. She was going to figure it out eventually.”
“Figure what out? That her dad has a small dick? Why would that ever come up?”
Linda shrugged against the pillow. “It came up tonight.”
“Because you brought it up.”
“Because the toilet seat came up. Metaphorically and literally.” She smiled in the dark. “I’m sorry if I embarrassed you. But honestly? It’s kind of nice that everyone knows now. I don’t have to pretend I don’t notice things.”
“Pretend you don’t notice what?”
“That you sit down. That you’re careful. That you’ve adapted.” Her hand slid lower, resting on my stomach. “I’ve always found it endearing, you know. The way you’ve just… accepted it. Made it work.”
“I haven’t accepted anything.”
“You sit down every time. That’s acceptance.”
“I sit down because it’s easier.”
“Because you’re small.”
“Because it’s easier.”
“Because you’re small and it’s easier.” She kissed my shoulder. “It’s okay. I love you anyway. Always have, always will.”
I lay there in the dark, listening to her breathing even out as she fell asleep, and tried to figure out why my chest felt so tight. It wasn’t just embarrassment—though there was plenty of that. It was something else, something I didn’t want to name.
The next morning, I went to the bathroom. The seat was up. I flipped it down, sat, and tried not to think about how everyone in the house now knew exactly why.
Through the wall, I could hear Brittany on the phone with someone—probably Jess.
“—no, I’m serious. My dad sits down to pee because he’s got, like, nothing. Mom just said it right there at dinner.”
I closed my eyes.
Some things, once known, can’t be unknown. And apparently, my penis size was now family knowledge.
I finished up, flushed, and went to make coffee.
The seat, at least, was down when I left.
The End.
*The opinions/views expressed in this story (and in any comments) are those of the author and do not represent this site. We support freedom of speech. This story has been submitted directly to this website for publication. Thanks for your submission.