Maybe After

An SPH Confession by Its_E_Cxxke.

Adult content warning. Under 18? Click to leave this website.

The first time Theo pulled his cock out for me, I genuinely didn’t know what to say.

Don’t get me wrong, I liked him. He was sweet, funny, good with his hands and his mouth, and he actually listened when I told him what I wanted in bed. But the first time I reached down and wrapped my fingers around him, I felt this odd little twist of disappointment. He was maybe four inches hard, and thin enough that my thumb and middle finger overlapped when I stroked him. Not a micropenis, not some freak-show dick, just… small. Undeniably, unforgivably, boringly small.

Normal sex with him was exactly that. Boring. He’d pump away on top of me, his little cock slipping in and out, and I’d lie there waiting for something—anything—to happen. Sometimes he’d hit a decent angle for a second or two, and I’d feel that spark of potential, but then he’d shift his weight or his rhythm would falter, and it would vanish. I’d fake a few moans, tell him it was good, and wait for him to finish. It wasn’t a bad relationship. It was just… underwhelming in the one place where I needed it not to be.

But he was the reason I got into this kink. The small-penis humiliation thing, the power play, the strap-on. All of it started with him.

We stumbled into it almost by accident. One night, after a few drinks and a long, lazy make-out session that had me soaked and aching, he rolled off me and reached for the condom drawer. I don’t know what came over me, but I caught his wrist and said, “Don’t bother. Get the toy instead.”

He blinked at me, confused at first. “What? Why?”

“Because I want actually to feel something tonight.”

The words came out sharper than I intended, and I saw the flash of hurt in his eyes. But something else flickered there too—something dark and interested. He hesitated for a long moment, then let out a shaky breath and shuffled over to the box under the bed. Inside was a harness and a thick, realistic dildo, maybe eight inches long and heavy as a proper cock. I’d bought it as a joke years earlier, before I met him, and it had mostly sat unused. Now, I was watching him fumble with the straps, and it felt like an inside joke was finally paying off.

That first time, he was clumsy. He pressed his own pathetic little erection flat against his stomach and buckled the harness over it, trapping it between his belly and the leather. The toy jutted out from his hips, enormous and veined, and when he turned back to me, I couldn’t help but laugh.

“God, look at you,” I said. “Now that’s a dick.”

He flushed bright red, but his cock twitched against the harness, leaking a clear little string of pre-cum down his stomach. I spread my legs and guided him between them, and when the head of the toy pressed against my pussy, slick and thick and there, I actually moaned for real.

He fucked me with it for a long time that night. Long enough to make me come twice. Long enough to make me forget, for whole minutes at a time, that the real thing trapped beneath the harness was barely half the size of the silicone monster inside me.

Afterward, he begged.

The begging became part of our ritual. Every time we got naked, we’d make out, and he’d go down on me—he was good with his tongue, I’ll give him that—and then, right when I was wet and needy, and he was reaching for the condom, I’d stop him.

“Toy,” I’d say.

“Come on, babe, please. Just this once. Let me do it for real.”

“Maybe after.” I’d smile sweetly. “Or maybe grow a few more inches, and I’ll let you.”

That line always got him. His little cock would flex against his abdomen, leaking everywhere, and he’d swallow his pride and start buckling the harness. I loved watching that moment—the shift from pleading to resignation, the way his body responded even as his ego deflated. His cock would be rock hard, four inches of useless, desperate flesh, pressed flat under the strap while the thick dildo bounced in front of him.

Then he’d fuck me. And God, it felt good. The toy filled me in ways he never could, stretching me, bottoming out, dragging against my g-spot until I couldn’t see straight. I moaned louder than I normally would on purpose, just to remind him of the difference. I’d gasp and arch my back and dig my nails into his shoulders and let out these high, breathy cries that I never once faked for his real cock.

“That’s it,” I’d pant. “Fuck me with that big dick. That’s how a real man fucks.”

He loved it. I know he did. The humiliation got him off harder than any blowjob I ever gave him. Half the time, the pressure of the toy grinding against his trapped cock made him come before I was even finished. He’d gasp and shudder and spill all over his own stomach, and I’d laugh and call him a premature little leak, and he’d blush furiously and keep pumping the toy into me until I got mine too.

After I came—sometimes more than once—the real fun started.

It went one of three ways.

Some nights, I’d leave him hanging. He’d be hard and trembling, his little cock smeared with his own pre-cum or the first pathetic spurt of his orgasm, and he’d reach for me with this needy, pleading look. “Please, babe. Just let me put it in. Please.”

“No,” I’d say, rolling onto my side. “I’m not in the mood anymore. You already came, didn’t you? That’s enough for you.”

Then I’d watch the frustration bloom on his face, the way his cock stayed hard but unsatisfied, bobbing uselessly. I’d smile and doze off while he dealt with the ache. Those nights were rare, but they were delicious.

More often, I’d let him finish in my hand. I’d sit up and stroke him slowly, barely gripping his four inches between my thumb and forefinger, while he bucked into my fist and begged. “Please, baby, let me put it in—just the tip. I promise I’ll make it good. Please.”

“I’ll just use my hand,” I’d say. “This is all you need.”

Sixty seconds, maybe two minutes. That was all it ever took for him to spurt over my fingers. He’d moan and curse and watch my relentless rhythm, and the whole time he’d keep asking for more, keep begging me to let him inside me as his little dick deserved it. I’d shake my head and slow down, tease the head with my thumb, and make him work for it. By the time he came, he was always trembling, humiliated, and so turned on he could barely form words.

But the nights I remember best were the ones I said yes to.

Those nights, I’d let him climb on top of me. But I’d lie flat on my front, press my thighs together tight, and bury my face in the pillow. He’d position himself between my legs, his cock straining toward my cunt, and slide in—barely. Just the tip. With my thighs clamped together, that was all he could reach. Four inches of cock, and ninety percent of it stayed outside.

He’d start to thrust, and I’d feel that shallow, frustrated little push. In and out, just the first inch or two, never enough. He’d grunt and strain, trying to force deeper, but my thighs wouldn’t part. And me? I’d reach for my phone.

I’d scroll through Instagram, check texts, maybe open a game. Totally silent. Totally bored. I’d yawn sometimes, let out a little sigh of impatience, shift my hips just enough to tease him without giving him any more. He’d keep pumping away, moaning and grunting and muttering my name, and I’d act like he wasn’t even there.

“You done yet?” I’d ask without looking up.

“Almost… almost, baby, please, can you just—”

“I’m busy. Hurry up.”

He’d finish hard, his little cock pulsing uselessly in that shallow little pocket, his cum leaking out around the seal of my thighs. Then he’d collapse on top of me, panting, and I’d pat his hip and roll away to clean up.

The best part was always the text he’d send me the next morning. Something small and needful. Did you enjoy last night? Was the toy better than me? And I’d type back a single word—always—and wait for the next time he begged to prove himself.

Because that was the thing about Theo: he never stopped trying. And I never stopped enjoying watching him fail.

We don’t talk anymore, him and me. But the kink stayed. And now and then, when I’m with someone new, I’ll lean in close and whisper the one thing that still gets me wet:

“Go get the big one. You’re not enough.”

 

The End.

 

Leave a Reply

Translate »