The Tie
A Gay SPH Experience by CheapChemistry4849.
We were lying in bed after one of those long, lazy Sunday afternoons where we’d had sex twice and were both still a little slick and satisfied. He was tracing circles on my stomach, and I was watching his fingers move, when he said, “You know you’re the third serious relationship I’ve had, right?”
I knew. He’d mentioned the others before. There was the high school sweetheart, the college girlfriend, and then me. Different decades, different versions of himself. I’d never asked for details because I didn’t need them. But that night, he wanted to talk.
“The weird thing,” he said, “is that none of you look anything alike.”
I raised an eyebrow. “What do you mean?”
“I mean physically. Different heights, different skin tones, different hair, different everything.” He paused, and I could feel him grinning in the dark. “But the more I thought about it, the more I realized you all have two things in common.”
“Okay,” I said, suddenly nervous. “What two things?”
He rolled onto his side, propped himself up on one elbow, and looked down at me. “A big ass,” he said, reaching around to squeeze mine for emphasis, “and a small dick.”
I laughed. I couldn’t help it. The way he said it, so casual, like he was telling me we all preferred the same brand of toothpaste.
“I’m serious,” he said, still grinning. “Think about it. Every single one of you. Big ass, tiny dick.”
“Tiny?” I repeated, my voice going up an octave. “You’ve never called it tiny before.”
“Small, then. Whatever you want to call it.” He shrugged. “The point is, I have a type, and apparently that type is thick-bottomed people with underwhelming equipment.”
I should have been offended. Any normal person would have been at least a little offended. But here’s the thing about my boyfriend: he’s not saying it to be mean. He’s saying it because he genuinely finds it funny, and because he knows I can take it, and because—and this is the part that still gets me—he actually prefers it that way.
The truth is, I’ve always known I was small. You don’t make it through 28 years of life without figuring that out. Gym class, locker rooms, the first time a girl in college unzipped your pants and made a face she tried really hard to hide—the evidence piles up. But hearing it from him, in bed, in that sleepy, satisfied voice, hit different. It wasn’t an insult. It was a fact. He was categorizing me, filing me away with the others, and the file was labeled “small dicks.”
I felt my face get hot. My tiny little cock, which had been soft and spent against my thigh, twitched. He noticed, because of course he did. He noticed everything.
“You like that,” he said, not a question.
I didn’t answer. I couldn’t. He reached down and wrapped his hand around my dick—his fingers covered the whole thing, tip to base, with room to spare—and gave it a gentle squeeze.
“Tell me about the others,” I said, my voice barely above a whisper. “Tell me how I compare.”
He laughed, low and warm. “You want to know?”
I nodded, my face still burning.
“Well,” he said, settling back against the pillows, “his first one was his high school sweetheart. They were together for almost three years, off and on. She was tiny—like, five feet tall, maybe a hundred pounds soaking wet—but she had this ridiculous, round ass that didn’t match the rest of her body at all. Like someone had glued a peach to a twig.”
“Her dick,” he continued, “was about the same size as yours. Two and a half inches soft, maybe four and a half hard on a good day. But thin. Really thin. Like a cocktail straw. He used to joke that he could close his hand around it and still have room for a couple of fingers.”
I swallowed. My own cock was pulsing in his grip now, trying desperately to get hard, but all it managed was a sad little throb. He didn’t seem to mind. He just kept talking, his thumb tracing slow circles over the tip.
“The second one—the college girlfriend—was different. Taller, curvier, built like a brick house. She had the biggest ass of the three, honestly. Just massive. And her dick was bigger than both of yours. Not by a lot, but noticeably. Maybe five inches hard, with some actual girth. He could actually feel it when she fucked him, which was rare.”
I didn’t miss the implication. He could actually feel it when she fucked him, unlike me. My cock, even at its hardest, was so thin and so short that when I rode him—when he let me ride him, which wasn’t often—he claimed he couldn’t feel much at all. He’d always been kind about it, but now the kindness was gone, replaced by this easy, brutal honesty that was making my head spin.
“I’m tied with the first one,” I said, more to myself than to him. “Tied for smallest.”
He nodded. “Yeah. You two are basically the same size. Hers might have been a little shorter, but yours is thinner. So it evens out.”
“Great,” I muttered. “Tied for last place.”
He laughed. “It’s not a competition, babe.”
But it was. It absolutely was, and I was losing. I was tied for last place with a girl he’d dated in high school, and the only thing keeping me from being dead last was a millimeter’s thickness. My cock, which he was still holding, felt impossibly small in his hand. I looked down and watched his fingers wrap around it, and I could see the head peeking out from the top of his fist, like a toy. A child’s toy. A joke.
“The other thing,” he said, and I could tell he was getting to the good part now, “is that he doesn’t really care to do anything with a dick.”
“What do you mean?”
“I mean, in all three relationships, the dynamic was the same. He’s the one who fucks. He’s the one who rides. He’s the one who gets off on being penetrated.” He paused, and I could feel his eyes on me in the dark. “The dick is just… there. He’ll touch it, sure. He’ll jerk you off if you ask, because he’s not an asshole. But he doesn’t crave it. He doesn’t fantasize about it. He doesn’t need it.”
I thought about all the times we’d had sex. How it was always him on top, or him on his back with his legs spread, pulling me down, telling me to eat him out while he touched himself. How he never asked me to fuck him, not seriously. How the few times I’d tried to initiate penetrative sex, he’d redirected me, pushed me down, climbed on top.
“You rarely ride me,” I said, and it came out more wounded than I intended.
He shrugged again. “It’s not my thing. And honestly?” He gave my cock another squeeze. “There’s not much to ride.”
I came. Right there, in his hand, without a single stroke. The humiliation of it, the weight of those words, the image of his high school sweetheart with her cocktail straw dick and his college girlfriend with her five inches of barely-adequate—it all crashed over me at once, and I felt my pitiful little cock spasm and leak a thin string of cum over his knuckles.
He laughed, genuinely delighted. “See? That’s what I mean. You don’t even need a dick to get off. Your brain does all the work.”
I lay there afterward, my face buried in the pillow, while he wiped his hand on the sheets and pulled me close. He kissed the back of my neck and said, “For what it’s worth, you’re his favorite. Biggest ass, best personality, and the smallest, most pathetic little dick of the bunch. It’s a winning combination.”
We both knew that last part was a lie, a kindness to soften the blow. But I took it. I took it, held onto it, and let it replay in my head for days afterward.
Because here’s the thing: I do have a small dick. I’ve always known that. But hearing him talk about it so casually, comparing me to his exes, ranking us by size, shape, and girth—it unlocked something in me. It made me want to be smaller. It made me want to send him photos of my cock next to everyday objects, so he could see exactly how thin it’s gotten, exactly how useless it is when I’m on top of him, exactly how little there is to ride.
He says he wishes he had photos of the others to compare. He wants to see the lineup, all three of us, side by side. He wants proof that he has a type. He wants to know if my cock is really as thin as hers was, if my ass is really as big, if the pattern holds.
I’m not sure I want to know. But I can’t stop thinking about it either.
Tied for smallest. Two and a half inches soft, four-ish hard, thin as a finger. A big ass and a small dick. His favorite combination.
The more I think about it, the more I want to prove him right. The more I want to be the smallest. Not tied for smallest—the smallest. The one he remembers when he’s old and gray, the one he tells his friends about when they’re comparing exes, the one he thinks about when he closes his eyes.
The one with the biggest ass and the most useless little cock.
The one who got off on being told there wasn’t much to ride.
The one who came in his hand just from hearing about it.
Apparently that’s me. Apparently that’s what I was always meant to be.
And the worst part—or the best part, depending on how you look at it—is that I can’t even be mad. He’s right. He’s been right all along.
Big ass. Small dick. Tied for last place.
And somehow, I’ve never been more turned on in my entire life.
The End.

