What She Meant by “Wish”

An SPH Experience by Bantam_Banana.

Adult content warning. Under 18? Click to leave this website.

I’ve never been the biggest guy. Four and a half inches hard, measured from the top, pressing the tape into that little pad of fat until it stops lying. Maybe a touch less if I’m not fully hard, maybe a touch more if she’s been talking dirty before I climb on top. But the number never changes much. 4.5. I’ve accepted it—most days.

My wife has been with exactly two men in her life: me and some frat guy she slept with once during college. She told me early on—almost apologetically, as if a low number were a flaw. I remember feeling lucky, not because I wanted an inexperienced woman, but because it meant there was only one other cock she could compare mine to. One other body. How bad could one comparison be?

For years, it didn’t come up. She never mentioned him. No drunken confessions, no nostalgic sighs. It was as if that night hadn’t happened. I let myself believe the memory had faded, or that it had been so unremarkable she never thought about it.

Then, last Saturday, she drank three glasses of wine too many and curled up beside me on the couch.

“I’m so glad I married you,” she said, her words soft and a little slurred. “Like, genuinely. You’re the best thing that ever happened to me.”

I smiled. “You’re drunk.”

“I’m honest.” She rested her head on my shoulder. “Can I tell you something?”

“Always.”

She paused. “I wish you’d been my first.”

I felt a little glow. Every man wants to hear that. “Yeah?”

“Yeah.” She toyed with the hem of her shirt. “Because he wasn’t the type of guy any girl wants as their first. It hurt. And he didn’t care.”

The glow flickered. “What do you mean, it hurt?”

She made a vague gesture toward her lap. “You know. Down there. He was just some random guy. Didn’t warm me up, didn’t ask if I was okay. Just shoved it in.” She winced at the memory. “I was sore for days.”

I should have left it alone. Every instinct told me to change the subject, to let her drift off to sleep and forget she’d said anything. But there’s a part of me—stupid, insecure, self-destructive—that always needs to know. I turned my head toward her.

“Why did it hurt? Was he… big?”

She went very still for a second. Then, slowly, she nodded. “Yeah. He was very, very big.”

The air in the room changed. I could hear my own pulse in my ears. “How big?”

“I don’t know. I didn’t measure.” She laughed, but it sounded nervous. “But I remember thinking, when I saw it, that there was no way it was going to fit. And it barely did. It hurt, but he didn’t care. He just kept pushing until he was all the way in.”

I stared at her profile. She was staring straight ahead at the dark TV screen, her cheeks flushed from wine or memory or both.

“Bigger than me?” I asked.

She flinched. Just a tiny jerk of her shoulders, but I felt it.

“That’s not— I didn’t mean it like that.”

“I didn’t ask if you meant it. I asked if he was bigger than me.”

Silence. The kind of silence that answers everything.

She finally looked at me, her eyes wide and a little glassy. “Can we not do this?”

“Do what? I’m just asking a question.”

“You’re doing that thing where you get all quiet and hurt,” she said. “I was trying to say something nice. I wish you’d been my first. That’s all.”

But the penny dropped then, hard and cold. If he had been average—or small, or even just my size—the pain she described wouldn’t have been the kind of thing she remembered years later. If he had been anywhere near me, she wouldn’t have used “very, very big” to explain why she wished she’d waited. The only way her “compliment” made sense was if she was telling me, without quite meaning to, that the one other cock she’d had in her life had been enormous. Much bigger than mine. And that the memory of it still lived somewhere in her head.

“So he was much bigger than me,” I said, my voice flat.

She closed her eyes. “Shut up now. I don’t want to talk about it.”

That was it—the point of no return.

She turned away from me, pulled the throw blanket up to her chin, and pretended to fall asleep within minutes. I sat there, stone still, replaying every word.

He was very, very big.
It hurt.
I wish you’d been my first.

My wife has had exactly two penises inside her. One of them is mine—four and a half inches, circumcised, slightly left-curving, not particularly thick. The other one was, apparently, so large that it caused her actual physical pain and left her sore for days. She remembered it clearly enough to bring it up unprovoked after years of marriage. She remembered the size, the ache, the carelessness. She remembered it all while I was sitting right next to her.

And now I couldn’t stop imagining it.

Later that night, after she’d fallen into a deep, wine-heavy sleep, I went into the bathroom and locked the door. I didn’t turn on the light. I just stood in the dark, unbuckled my jeans, and took out my cock. Soft at first, then hardening as I thought about the way she’d said: “very, very big.” I thought about her at nineteen, on her back in some dorm room, legs pushed apart by a frat boy’s shoulders. I thought about a cock so thick she couldn’t close her hand around it, so long it hit places that made her cry out. I thought about her small, inexperienced pussy stretching around it, her fingers digging into the sheets, her mouth open in pain while he just kept pushing.

And then I looked down at my own erection—four and a half inches. The head barely clearing my fist. I curled my fingers around it—thumb overlapping forefinger easily—and felt the full weight of what she’d told me.

Her first sexual experience had been with a monster cock. Her second, her only other point of reference, was me. If she closed her eyes, could she compare the two? Could she feel the difference every time we had sex? Did she miss the stretch? The fullness? The way it had hurt?

I stroked myself slowly, not because I was horny, but because I needed the physical release—something to burn off the shame coiling in my stomach. My cock felt small and inadequate in my hand. I imagined what she must feel when I’m inside her. After a cock that split her open and left her sore for days, my four and a half inches must feel like a finger. A warm, familiar, but utterly unremarkable presence. She’d never once told me I was big. She’d never once complained that I hurt her. She’d never once looked at me the way I now pictured her looking at him.

I came into the toilet bowl in under two minutes, my cock jerking weakly in my grip, and the orgasm barely registered. There was no pleasure in it—just humiliation.

When I went back to bed, she was still asleep. I lay down beside her, my hands folded over my chest, and stared at the ceiling until sunrise.

The next morning, she acted as nothing had happened. She made coffee, kissed my forehead, asked if I’d slept okay. I said yes. I didn’t bring it up. Neither did she.

But I know now what she meant when she said she wished I’d been her first. It wasn’t that she thought I would have been gentle, or loving, or more careful. It was that she wished she’d never had the memory of that huge cock inside her—because without it, my small one would have been enough. Without it, she wouldn’t have anything to compare me to.

She’ll never say it again. I know that. She clammed up the moment the words left her mouth, and now she’ll bury it even deeper. But it doesn’t matter. I heard it. I understood it.

And I’ll never stop thinking about it.

 

The End.

 

Leave a Reply

Translate »