Lost & Found
An SPH Experience by joecooltheman1977.
She was twenty-four, same as me. Worked at a marketing firm downtown, had her own apartment, paid her own bills—grown-up stuff. I was still feeling my way through adulthood, literally and figuratively.
That night, she’d cooked dinner at her place. Nothing fancy—pasta, wine, candles she’d lit when I walked in. The intention was obvious, and I’d been hard since we sat down to eat.
By the time we made it to her bedroom, I was aching. I fumbled the condom out of my wallet—probably stupid to keep it there, but I didn’t exactly need them often—and rolled it on with shaking hands. Standard Trojans. The kind you could buy at any gas station.
Rachel was on her back, knees spread, watching me with this lazy smile. She had a great body. Soft in all the right places, with hips that fit perfectly in my hands. I climbed over her, lined myself up, and pushed inside.
She felt amazing. Warm and wet and tight. I tried to pace myself, but I was too turned on. Three minutes, maybe four, and I was groaning into her neck, coming harder than I had in weeks.
I stayed inside her for a moment, catching my breath. Then I pulled out, rolled onto my back, and reached down to take the condom off.
My hand found nothing.
I froze. Patted the sheets. Felt around my thighs, the bed beneath me. Nothing.
“What’s wrong?” Rachel asked, propping herself up on her elbows.
“I think—the condom—”
“What?”
“I can’t find it.”
She stared at me. Then laughed. “What do you mean you can’t find it?”
“I mean it’s not on me anymore.” I sat up, searching the sheets more frantically. “It must have slipped off.”
“Slipped off?” She sat up too, reaching between her legs. “Inside me?”
“I don’t—maybe?”
Rachel reached down, two fingers sliding into herself. Her face scrunched in concentration. Then her expression shifted—something between surprise and amusement—and she pulled her hand back out.
The condom dangled from her fingertips, translucent and wet with both of us.
“There it is,” she said.
My face went hot. “I didn’t—sorry, I didn’t feel it come off.”
“Obviously.” She dropped it into the trash can by her nightstand, then grabbed a tissue to clean herself up. She didn’t seem upset. More… amused.
I sat there, naked, trying to figure out what to say. Sorry I lost a condom inside you didn’t seem right.
Rachel wiped herself off, tossed the tissue, and turned back to me. She was still naked, completely comfortable, while I wanted to crawl under the bed and die.
“Has that happened before?” she asked.
“No.” I shook my head. “Never.”
“Huh.” She tilted her head, studying me in a way that made me want to cover myself. “I mean, I’ve heard of it happening. Just didn’t think—” She stopped herself, smiling.
“Think what?”
“Nothing.”
“Rachel.”
She looked down at my lap. At my soft cock, resting against my thigh. Maybe two inches, tops. Thin. The kind of size that disappeared completely when I was sitting down.
“You need to find condoms that actually fit your small dick,” she said.
The words hit me like cold water.
“I—” My mouth opened and closed. “They do fit.”
“Babe.” She gestured at the trash can. “They clearly don’t.”
“That was—a fluke. It never—”
“It came off inside me because nothing was keeping it on.” She said it simply, matter-of-factly. No cruelty in her tone, but no softness either. Just the truth. “Standard condoms are made for average guys. You’re not average.”
My face burned. My chest felt tight. But underneath the shame, something else twitched—something I didn’t want to acknowledge.
“I know how big I am,” I said quietly.
“Do you?”
“Yes.”
“So you know you need smaller condoms.” She shrugged. “It’s not a big deal. Just—order some online. They make them.”
She said it like it was nothing. Like telling me my dick was small was the same as telling me I needed a different size shirt.
“I didn’t know they made—special sizes,” I admitted.
“They do.” She lay back down, stretching out beside me, completely unbothered. “Snugger fit. For guys who are—” She waved her hand vaguely. “You know.”
“Small?”
“Below average.” She smiled, reaching over to pat my thigh. “It’s fine. I don’t mind. Just don’t want to fish another one out of me.”
I didn’t know what to say. So I said nothing. Just lay there, staring at the ceiling, feeling her words echo in my head.
You need to find condoms that actually fit your small dick.
Later that night, after she’d fallen asleep, I looked it up on my phone. Snugger fit condoms. For men with “below average endowment.”
I ordered a box. Then I jerked off in her bathroom, thinking about her pulling that condom out of herself and looking at me with that flat, knowing expression.
—
It became a thing between us after that. Not mean—never mean. But whenever I reached for a condom, she’d ask, “The right ones?” And she’d smile, and I’d get hard, and she’d notice, and we’d both pretend she hadn’t noticed. Some things don’t need to be said out loud.
The End.
*The opinions/views expressed in this story (and in any comments) are those of the author and do not represent this site. We support freedom of speech. This story has been submitted directly to this website for publication. Thanks for your submission.