Going Through the Motions
An SPH Experience by SubMark21.
Let me back up.
The sex always started the same way, and honestly, that part was great. We’d be on her bed or mine, depending on whose apartment we were at that night, and we’d kiss. Lauren was a good kisser—soft lips, patient, the kind of girl who kissed like she had all the time in the world. I’d run my hands over her body, and she’d let me, her skin warm under my palms. She had a great body. Not that it matters to the story, but it does to me—she was about five-foot-six, with curves in all the right places, soft hips, full breasts that fit perfectly in my hands. I loved touching her. I loved the little sounds she made when I found the right spot, the way her breath would catch when I traced my fingers along the inside of her thigh.
The foreplay was good. Better than good. I’d go down on her, and that’s where things came alive. I’d kiss my way down her stomach, pull her panties off slowly, and bury my face between her legs. I’d lick her clit in slow circles, build up the pressure, read her body—her back arching, her hands gripping the sheets, her thighs squeezing my head. I got good at it. I had to get good at it, though I didn’t fully understand that yet. I’d slide a finger inside her while I worked her clit with my tongue, curling it upward, and she’d gasp. Sometimes I’d use two fingers. Sometimes we’d bring out the toy—a purple vibrator she kept in her nightstand drawer—and I’d hold it against her while I licked, and she’d come hard. Real hard. Her whole body would tense, her stomach would flex, and she’d let out this breathless, shaking moan that made me feel like a god.
That was the part where I felt like a man.
Then it was my turn.
She’d catch her breath, sometimes pull me up for a kiss, and then she’d lean back. That was the signal—the shift. I could feel it happening every time, like a door closing slowly between us. The energy in the room would change. The heat, the urgency, the aliveness that had been there while I was going down on her—it would drain out, like someone pulled a plug.
I’d reach for the nightstand and grab a condom. I’d tear the wrapper open, roll it on, and kneel between her legs. My cock was hard—always hard by that point, because going down on her turned me on more than anything. But my cock, when it’s hard, is about four inches. Maybe four on a good day, if I’m being optimistic. Thin, too. Not dramatically thin, but enough that I’d noticed condoms didn’t fit snug. There was always extra room at the tip, that bunched-up reservoir that was designed for guys who actually filled it.
I’d get in position. She’d open her legs a little wider, and I’d line myself up. The first push in—I always watched her face—every single time. I was looking for something. A gasp. A wince. A moan. Anything that would tell me she felt it. That she felt me.
Nothing.
I’d slide in, and her face would stay the same. Relaxed. Neutral. Like I’d just handed her a glass of water. Her eyes would be on me, soft and present, but not aroused. Not hungry. Not lost in it. Just… there.
I’d start slow. Long, deliberate strokes, trying to feel every inch of myself inside her, trying to make those inches count. I’d push in as deep as I could, grinding my hips against hers, hoping the pressure on her clit would do something. I’d pull back slow, then push in again. And I’d watch her face the whole time.
Nothing.
No reaction. No change in breathing. No shift in her expression. She’d just lie there, her arms resting at her sides or maybe lightly on my back, her body still and open beneath me. I could feel her inside—warm, wet from earlier, soft—but there was no grip. No squeeze. No resistance. It was like my dick was swimming in space, barely touching the walls of her pussy. I’d thrust deeper, trying to find something, some corner where I could feel her, where she could feel me, but there was just… warmth. Wetness. Emptiness.
So I’d go faster.
I’d pick up the pace, pumping harder, trying to generate some friction, some intensity. I’d grab her hips and pull her into me, slamming forward with everything I had. My bed would creak. The headboard would tap the wall. My breathing would get heavy and ragged. I was giving it everything. Every muscle in my body was engaged, my arms shaking from holding myself up, my hips driving forward like I was trying to break through something.
And she’d just… lie there.
I’d look down at her, and she’d be looking up at me. Her eyes were soft. Her expression was calm. Not pained, not bored exactly—just neutral. Like she was waiting for a bus, and then, while I was sweating and grunting and thrusting as hard as I could, she’d reach up and stroke my face.
That gesture. That fucking gesture.
It was gentle. Tender, even. She’d run her fingers along my jaw, brush a strand of hair off my forehead, and look at me with these kind, patient eyes. And it destroyed me every time, because I knew what it meant. It wasn’t passion. It wasn’t desire. It was comfort. She was comforting me as if I were a child struggling with something difficult. Like I was doing my best, and she was proud of me for trying.
She wasn’t moaning. She wasn’t breathing hard. Her body wasn’t tense, trembling, or responding in any way to what I was doing. Her legs would be open, flat against the bed or maybe bent slightly at the knees, but they weren’t wrapping around me. Her hips weren’t moving with mine. She was just… there. A warm body beneath me that happened to have a hole I could put my dick in. And even that hole didn’t seem to know I was there.
I’d keep going. What else was I going to do? Stop? Acknowledge out loud what we both clearly knew? I couldn’t. So I’d fuck harder. Faster. Chasing something—friction, sensation, validation, I don’t know. My cock would slide in and out, and I could feel myself getting close, the pressure building at the base, my balls tightening. And the whole time, the silence from her end was deafening. No sound. No movement. Just that soft, patient gaze and the occasional stroke of her fingers across my cheek.
When I came, it was almost a relief. Not because it felt amazing—it did, physically, in the way that an orgasm always feels good—but because it meant it was over. The performance was done. I could stop pretending that this was working.
I’d groan, push in deep, and cum into the condom. My body would tense, my hips jerking, and for a few seconds I’d forget about everything except the release. Then it would hit me. The wave of exhaustion, yes, but also the weight of what had just happened. Or rather, what hadn’t.
I’d pull out, and I could see the condom hanging loosely on my softening dick, the latex bunched and wrinkled, barely clinging. The tip was filled, but the shaft looked deflated, like a balloon three days after a party. I’d try not to look at it. I’d roll off her and collapse onto my back, chest heaving, sweat dripping down my temples, my breath coming in ragged gasps as I’d just run a sprint.
And Lauren would lie there for a moment. Not catching her breath—she had no breath to catch. She hadn’t exerted herself at all. Then she’d sit up, swing her legs off the bed, and stretch. Casual. Unhurried. Like she was getting up on a Sunday morning.
And then she’d say it.
“Good job.”
That’s what she’d say. Good job. Sometimes with a little pat on my chest or my shoulder. Sometimes with a soft smile. And the tone—that’s what killed me. It was the tone you’d use with a kid who just finished a puzzle. Or a dog who finally learned to sit. Warm. Encouraging and patronizing in the most devastating way possible, because it wasn’t intentional. She wasn’t trying to humiliate me. She was being genuine. She genuinely thought I’d done my best, and she genuinely wanted me to feel okay about it.
Which meant she genuinely knew I had nothing to work with.
She’d get up and walk to the bathroom, completely unbothered. Not in a hurry, not lingering. Just… done. Like the whole thing had been a minor item on a checklist, make boyfriend feel good about his penis. Check. I’d lie there on the bed, still panting, staring at the ceiling, and listen to the water running in the bathroom. She’d come back in a few minutes, pull on a shirt or a pair of panties, and get back into bed as nothing had happened.
And the worst part—the absolute worst part—was that she’d already cum. Earlier. When my mouth was on her. When my fingers were inside her. When the vibrator was pressed against her clit. She’d had a real, full, body-shaking orgasm, and it had nothing to do with my dick. My dick was the afterthought. The courtesy. The thing she tolerated because I needed to get off too, and she loved me enough to let me go through the motions.
I’d lie awake after she fell asleep, staring at the ceiling or scrolling through my phone, and the thoughts would spiral. Does she feel anything when I’m inside her? Has she ever faked it with me? Is she thinking about someone else? Does she talk about this with her friends? Does she tell them that her boyfriend has a small dick and can’t make her feel anything during sex?
I measured myself again that night. I’d done it before, but I did it again. 3.9 inches. I pressed the ruler harder into my pubic bone. 4.1, if I counted the fat. But the fat didn’t count. The part that went inside her was less than four inches, and it was thin enough that she couldn’t feel it after fingers and toys had stretched her out.
That was the math. Cold, hard, brutal math.
I started avoiding sex. Not obviously—I didn’t stop it entirely—but I’d find reasons to go down on her and then not follow up. I’d make her cum with my mouth and then pull her close and say I was tired, or that I just wanted to hold her. She never complained. She never asked why. And that silence was its own answer. She didn’t miss it. She didn’t need my dick inside her. It was an optional add-on that she could take or leave, and she was fine leaving it.
One night, about two months into this pattern, she caught me off guard. We were lying in bed after I’d gone down on her, and she was still catching her breath from a particularly intense orgasm. I was hard—painfully hard—pressing against her thigh through my boxers. She reached down and touched it through the fabric.
“You don’t have to hold back,” she said softly. “You can go if you want.”
Go if you want. Not I want you inside me. Not I need you. Just… you can go if you want. Permission. Like I was asking to use the bathroom.
I almost said something. I almost asked her—do you even feel me? When I’m inside you, does it do anything for you? But the words got stuck somewhere in my throat, tangled up with pride and shame and the knowledge that I didn’t actually want to hear the answer.
I shook my head. “I’m good,” I said.
She smiled. That same warm, patient smile. And she kissed my forehead.
“Okay,” she said. “Good job tonight.”
And she rolled over and went to sleep.
I stayed awake for a long time after that. My erection eventually faded, shrinking down to its resting size—barely two and a half inches, soft and small against my thigh. I looked at it in the dim light of the bedroom. It looked harmless. Insignificant. Like something that belonged on a boy, not a man.
I thought about every time I’d been inside her. Every thrust. Every attempt to go harder, faster, deeper. Every time I’d watched her face for a reaction and found nothing. Every time she’d stroked my cheek while I pumped away as my life depended on it: every good job and every casual exit to the bathroom.
She never said I was small. She never laughed. She never made a cruel joke or a dismissive comment. She never did anything that could be called humiliation—not on purpose. But the absence of her response was worse than any laugh. The dead fish. The neutral face. The gentle, motherly touch on my cheek while I fucked her with everything I had and got nothing back.
It was the kindness that humiliated me. Because kindness meant she knew. She knew, and she was handling it the way you handle a person with a limitation—gently, patiently, with encouraging words and soft touches and the unspoken understanding that this was as good as it was going to get.
Good job.
I’m still with her. I don’t know why. Love, maybe. Comfort. The fact that when my mouth is on her, she comes alive, and for those moments, I feel like I matter. But when it’s my turn—when I’m on top of her, inside her, giving everything I have—she’s somewhere else. And I’m left panting on my back, staring at the ceiling, wondering if four inches will ever be enough for anyone.
I don’t think it will.
The End.
*The opinions/views expressed in this story (and in any comments) are those of the author and do not represent this site. We support freedom of speech. This story has been submitted directly to this website for publication. Thanks for your submission.