The Extender
An SPH Experience by Catness33.
Bonnie and her boyfriend Eddie were sitting at the island. Isla and her guy Jude were on the couch. And my girlfriend, Zara, was leaning against the counter, watching me work with that soft smile she gets when I’m doing something she’s proud of.
For a few hours, everything was perfect. The food was good, the drinks were strong, and the conversation flowed easy. We talked about work, about travel, about the gym they all went to together. I felt like a good host as I belonged in this group.
Then Bonnie set down her wine glass and said, “Okay, let’s really get to know each other. Spill it—what’s the craziest thing you’ve done as a couple?”
Isla went first. “We had sex on our hotel balcony at the beach. In the middle of the day. People could definitely see.”
Bonnie laughed and followed up. “Eddie ate me out on a long road trip. I was driving. He almost caused an accident.”
Everyone turned to Zara. She set her drink down, a slow grin spreading across her face. “We actually went to a sex shop recently. Bought a toy.”
The girls rolled their eyes in unison. “Yeah, who hasn’t, Zara? Get real.”
She held up a hand. “No, wait. Lyle hasn’t been lasting long lately. And he’s never been… y’know, huge. So we got an extender.”
The room went quiet for a beat. Then the girls perked up, leaning forward. Eddie let out a sharp laugh. Jude grinned and shook his head.
“A what?” Isla asked, her eyes wide.
Zara looked at me—that same smirk from the Magnum comment, but bigger now. More confident. She was showing off. “It’s like a dildo he wears over his dick. Lyle, go get it.”
I froze. The spatula in my hand dripped sauce onto the stove. Everyone turned to look at me. Eddie had his eyebrows raised. Jude was grinning. The girls were staring with open curiosity.
I set the spatula down and wiped my hands on a towel. “Uh. Yeah. One sec.”
I walked to the bedroom on autopilot. Opened the drawer. Pulled out the extender—this flesh-colored silicone sleeve with a hollow base and a thick, veined shaft jutting out. It sat in my palm like an accusation.
I came back to the living room. Zara took it from me and held it up like a trophy.
Bonnie reached out and touched it, her fingers tracing the ridges. “That’s… honestly about Eddie’s size,” she said.
Eddie puffed up his chest, grinning.
Isla grabbed it next and weighed it in her hand. “That’s my minimum,” she said, a wicked grin spreading across her face.
Everyone laughed. Eddie high-fived Jude. The girls passed the extender around like a show-and-tell item, inspecting it and commenting on its texture, size, and shape. I stood in the middle of my kitchen, watching my girlfriend beam with pride at the humiliation she’d just orchestrated.
—
After we cleared the dishes, Bonnie suggested we play a game. “Let’s make it interesting. Loser does a naked lap around the backyard.”
I looked at Zara. She shrugged. “Backyard’s fenced in. It’s fine.”
We played. Six rounds of some card game I don’t even remember. And somehow—somewhere, the girls all coordinated to gang up on me. Every hand, they worked together to make sure I lost. The guys laughed. Zara laughed. I lost.
“Alright, Lyle,” Bonnie said, pointing toward the sliding glass door. “Strip and run.”
I stood there. Eight eyes on me. Zara nodded encouragingly, like she was sending me off the high dive.
I peeled off my shirt. Dropped my pants. My underwear. I stood naked in my living room, soft and small, my cock shrinking under the combined weight of four women’s stares.
“Oh,” Bonnie said, her voice flat. “Now I see why he needs the extender.”
Isla covered her mouth, laughing. “Oh, you poor girl, Zara.”
Eddie and Jude were both grinning, arms crossed, enjoying the show.
I didn’t say anything. I slid open the door and ran. The cool night air hit my skin, the grass wet under my feet as I sprinted the perimeter of the yard. Twenty seconds. Maybe less. I came back to the door, panting, still naked.
“Put on the extender,” Zara said, her voice soft but firm. “Then you can put your clothes on.”
I looked at her. She wasn’t joking.
I picked the thing up off the coffee table, pulled it on, and felt the silicone stretch over me. Suddenly, I had six inches. Suddenly, I looked like a man.
They watched as I pulled my briefs up over the fake cock, then my jeans. The bulge was obscene, heavy, impossible to ignore.
“There,” Zara said, patting my chest. “Now you pass.”
—
We stayed up another hour. The girls went back to talking about the gym. The guys drank more. And I sat there in my jeans with a dildo strapped to my waist, feeling like a fraud wearing a Halloween costume that everyone knew was fake.
When everyone finally left, Zara came up behind me and wrapped her arms around my waist. “You were a good sport tonight.”
“Mmm.”
She pressed her lips to my shoulder. “You know I love you, right?”
I nodded.
“But you get it, don’t you? Why does the extender help?”
I turned around and looked at her. “I get it.”
She kissed me softly, then pulled back with that same smirk. “Good. Now leave it on for bed. I want to pretend, just for one night.”
She walked to the bedroom, leaving me standing in the kitchen, still wearing the leash strapped between my legs.
The End.
*The opinions/views expressed in this story (and in any comments) are those of the author and do not represent this site. We support freedom of speech. This story has been submitted directly to this website so that we can publish it here. Thanks for your submission.