Mistaken Identity
A Gay Fictional SPH Story by RogerTheDodger88.
“Indecent exposure,” Detective Morrison said, sliding a folder across the table. “Three separate incidents. Women identified you from a photo lineup.”
“That’s impossible,” Daniel said, his voice cracking. “I would never—”
“Save it.” Morrison flipped open the folder. “CCTV caught our guy clear as day. Park bathroom, the alley behind the coffee shop on Elm, and the jogging trail off Cedar.”
Daniel leaned forward, looking at the grainy stills. His stomach dropped.
The first photo showed a man in a gray hoodie, face partially obscured, standing with his pants pulled down. But what made Daniel’s breath catch wasn’t the man’s face—it was what hung between his legs.
A massive, thick cock, easily nine inches soft, draped over a pair of enormous, hairy balls that looked like they belonged on a bull.
“That’s… that’s not me,” Daniel whispered.
“Really.” Morrison’s voice was flat. “Because three separate witnesses picked your photo.”
“Look at the picture! Look at—” Daniel gestured frantically at the screen. “I don’t have… I’m not built like that.”
The detective studied him for a long moment. Then sighed and pulled out another form.
“Fine. We’ll need to verify. Strip.”
“What?”
“You heard me. We need to confirm you’re not the man in these photos. Officer Reyes will document.”
Daniel’s face burned. The thought of exposing himself in a police station made him want to disappear. But the alternative was being charged for crimes he didn’t commit.
He stood on shaking legs and unbuttoned his jeans.
—
Officer Reyes was efficient, professional, and completely unfazed as she held the camera. She’d seen plenty in her eight years on the force. But even she had to suppress a small sound of surprise when Daniel pushed his boxers down.
His cock was barely visible—a tiny nub, maybe an inch and a half soft, nestled against his pelvis. His balls were small and completely smooth, drawn tight against his body.
“Jesus,” Morrison muttered, looking up from his paperwork. “That’s definitely not our guy.”
Reyes snapped several photos, making sure to capture the clear difference between Daniel’s body and the suspect’s impressive endowment.
“Mr. Walsh,” Morrison said, his tone shifting from accusatory to almost sympathetic, “you’re free to go. We apologize for the inconvenience.”
Daniel pulled his pants up as quickly as his trembling hands would allow. But before he could reach the door, it swung open.
A tall, broad-shouldered man was escorted in by another officer, his wrists cuffed. He had a cocky grin and wore the same gray hoodie as in the CCTV footage.
“Well, well,” the man said, his eyes sweeping over Daniel with amusement. “They grab you by mistake too, little guy?”
Daniel froze.
The man—introduced as Connor Hayes—laughed, a deep, rich sound. “Don’t worry. I confessed. Told them I was the one showing off the goods to those pretty ladies.” He winked at Reyes. “Can’t help it if I’m proud of what God gave me.”
Morrison uncuffed Hayes and began processing the real suspect. But Hayes didn’t leave immediately. He stepped closer to Daniel, who couldn’t seem to move his feet.
“Hey,” Hayes said, his voice dropping lower, “I saw the photos they took of you.”
Daniel’s face went white.
“Interesting contrast, isn’t it?” Hayes’s smile was predatory. “They had us side by side on the monitor. Me with my big, thick cock and heavy, hairy balls… and you with that tiny little button and smooth little marbles.”
“Please—” Daniel started.
“No, no, don’t be embarrassed.” Hayes leaned in, his breath warm against Daniel’s ear. “I’m actually into it. The contrast, I mean. Gets me hard thinking about how different we are.”
Daniel’s tiny cock twitched in his pants—a movement that didn’t go unnoticed by Hayes.
“Oh,” Hayes breathed, his grin widening. “You like this? Being reminded how small you are?”
Daniel couldn’t speak. Couldn’t move. His face was on fire, but something else was happening too—something he’d buried deep for years. A shameful, secret thrill at being exposed, being compared, being found lacking.
Hayes glanced at the officers, who were busy with paperwork, paying them no attention.
“Come with me,” Hayes murmured. “My place. Thirty minutes. I’ll text you the address.”
He slipped a piece of paper into Daniel’s pocket, his fingers brushing against Daniel’s hip.
“You can say no,” Hayes said, his voice surprisingly gentle despite the filthy words. “But I think you won’t. I think you’ve been waiting your whole life for someone to see you—really see you—and not look away.”
—
Daniel stood outside apartment 4B, his hand raised to knock. Every rational part of his brain screamed at him to turn around, go home, forget this ever happened. But his feet wouldn’t move.
The door opened before he could knock.
Hayes stood in the doorway, shirtless, wearing only loose sweatpants that did nothing to hide the massive bulge swinging between his legs. He smiled and stepped aside.
“Come in, little guy.”
The apartment was nice—clean, modern, with a view of the city. But Daniel barely noticed. His eyes were fixed on Hayes.
“Strip for me,” Hayes said, settling onto the couch. “Let me see that tiny cock again. The one that got you almost arrested.”
Daniel’s hands moved before his brain could catch up. He unbuttoned his shirt, let it fall. Pulled down his jeans. His boxers followed, pooling at his ankles.
He stood naked in front of a stranger, his micropenis completely exposed.
Hayes whistled low. “Even smaller than I remembered. What is that, an inch? Inch and a half?”
“Two,” Daniel whispered. “When it’s… when I’m hard.”
“Hard?” Hayes laughed. “Show me. Get that little nub hard for me.”
Daniel’s hand moved to his cock, his fingers barely needing to stroke—the whole thing fit between his thumb and forefinger. He closed his eyes, humiliation washing over him, and felt himself stiffen to his full two inches.
“Pathetic,” Hayes said, but his voice was thick with arousal. “Absolutely pathetic. And these—” He reached out, his large hand cupping Daniel’s smooth, tiny balls. “Like little grapes. Completely smooth. I bet you’ve never made a woman cum with this equipment.”
Daniel whimpered, his tiny cock throbbing.
“Meanwhile,” Hayes said, standing and pushing down his sweatpants, “look at what I’m working with.”
His cock sprang free—thick, heavy, at least nine inches long, soft, with a prominent vein running along the top. His balls were enormous, covered in dark hair, hanging low in their sack.
“This is what a real man looks like,” Hayes said, wrapping his hand around his shaft. “This is what women scream for. What you can never have.”
Daniel stared, mesmerized by the sheer size difference.
“On your knees,” Hayes commanded. “Worship a real cock.”
Daniel dropped. He pressed his face against Hayes’s heavy balls, inhaling the musky scent. His tongue darted out, licking the hairy sack while his tiny cock leaked onto the floor.
“Good little guy,” Hayes groaned. “That’s it. Show me how much you appreciate a real man’s equipment.”
Daniel worked his tongue higher, licking up the massive shaft. He couldn’t even wrap his hand around the girth. Hayes’s cock began to harden, growing even longer—easily eleven inches now, thick as Daniel’s wrist.
“Suck it,” Hayes ordered. “Open that mouth wide.”
Daniel stretched his jaw as wide as he could, taking just the head into his mouth. It was overwhelming—hot, thick, filling his mouth completely. He bobbed his head, taking maybe four inches before his throat protested.
“Can’t even take half,” Hayes taunted. “Pathetic. But you look so pretty trying.”
Hayes grabbed Daniel’s head and began fucking his mouth, shallow thrusts that still made Daniel gag. Tears streamed down his face, drool coating his chin.
“Play with that tiny cock,” Hayes said. “Let me see you jerk that little thing while I use your throat.”
Daniel’s fingers found his micropenis, rubbing the small shaft frantically. The humiliation, the size difference, the overwhelming presence of Hayes’s massive cock—it all combined into a shameful, intense arousal.
“Gonna cum,” Hayes grunted. “Gonna paint that face with a real man’s load.”
He pulled out and stroked his huge cock twice before erupting. Thick ropes of cum splattered across Daniel’s face—his forehead, his cheeks, his lips. It seemed endless, wave after wave of hot seed.
Daniel came too, his tiny cock spurting a few small drops onto the floor, his whole body shaking.
“Fuck,” Hayes breathed, looking down at Daniel’s cum-covered face. “That was hot.”
He grabbed his phone and snapped a picture before Daniel could protest.
“For my collection,” Hayes said with a wink. “Now clean up. I want to go again in twenty minutes. And this time, I’m going to compare us properly. Side by side. Photos for the whole night.”
Daniel looked up at him, cum dripping from his chin, his two-inch cock already starting to harden again.
“Yes,” he whispered. “Please.”
—
Daniel wiped his face with the tissue Hayes handed him, but the smell of cum lingered on his skin. His cheeks burned as he knelt on the hardwood floor, his tiny cock already stiffening again despite—or because of—the shame coursing through him.
“Bathroom’s down the hall,” Hayes said, gesturing lazily with one hand while the other scratched at his heavy, hairy balls. “Clean up properly. I want you presentable for our little photo session.”
Daniel stood on shaky legs and made his way to the bathroom. The mirror above the sink showed a man he barely recognized—flushed face, swollen lips, dried cum on his chin. He turned on the faucet and splashed cold water on his face, then stared at his reflection.
His cock hung between his legs, barely visible. A nub. A joke.
He thought about leaving. He could walk out the door, go home, pretend this never happened. But his feet stayed planted on the tile. His hand drifted down to his smooth, tiny balls, rolling them between his fingers.
Two inches. That was all he had to offer.
He dried off and returned to the living room.
Hayes had set up a tripod with a camera mounted on top, aimed at the couch. He’d also laid out a measuring tape on the coffee table.
“Perfect,” Hayes said, his eyes sweeping over Daniel’s naked body. “Come here. Stand next to me.”
Hayes pulled off his sweatpants, revealing his massive cock swinging freely. Even soft, it hung past his mid-thigh. His balls were enormous, covered in dark curls.
“Let’s get a comparison shot,” Hayes said, wrapping an arm around Daniel’s shoulders. “Show the world the difference between a real man and a little guy like you.”
Daniel’s breath caught. “You’re going to share those photos?”
Hayes laughed. “Maybe. If you’re good, now hold still.”
He positioned them side by side, their hips touching. Daniel’s tiny cock looked even smaller next to Hayes’s heavy, thick member.
“Get hard for me,” Hayes commanded. “Both of us.”
Daniel watched as Hayes stroked himself to full mast—eleven inches of thick, veiny cock jutting out proudly. Daniel’s own hand moved to his micropenis, rubbing the small shaft until it reached its full two inches.
“Jesus,” Hayes breathed, snapping a photo. “The contrast is incredible. I’m literally five times your size.”
He took several more pictures from different angles—overhead shots showing the length difference, close-ups of their balls side by side, one with Hayes’s cock resting on Daniel’s tiny erection, completely dwarfing it.
“Now,” Hayes said, setting the camera down, “I want to try something.”
He sat on the couch and spread his legs wide. His massive cock and heavy balls were on full display.
“Sit on my lap. Facing me.”
Daniel hesitated, then climbed onto Hayes’s lap, his knees sinking into the couch cushions on either side of Hayes’s thick thighs. His tiny cock pressed against Hayes’s stomach, leaving a small smear of precum.
Hayes reached down and grabbed both of their cocks in one large hand. His fingers wrapped easily around his own thick shaft, but Daniel’s micropenis was barely a nub in his palm.
“Feel that?” Hayes growled, stroking them together. “Feel how much bigger I am?”
Daniel whimpered, his hips bucking weakly. The sensation was overwhelming—Hayes’s hot, hard cock pressing against his tiny erection, the friction sending sparks up his spine.
“This is what a real cock feels like,” Hayes continued, his voice low. “Heavy. Thick. Something you can actually stroke. Something that fills a pussy or an ass. Not this—” He squeezed Daniel’s cock, making him gasp. “—this little thing. This useless nub.”
“Please—” Daniel moaned.
“Please what? Please stop? Or please keep going?”
“Keep going. Please don’t stop.”
Hayes laughed. “That’s what I thought. You love this. Being reminded of your place.”
He released their cocks and grabbed Daniel’s hips, lifting him slightly. Daniel felt the head of Hayes’s massive cock pressing against his entrance.
“Ever taken something this big?” Hayes asked.
Daniel shook his head. “I’ve never… no one’s ever…”
“Virgin ass?” Hayes’s grin widened. “Even better.”
He reached for a bottle of lube on the end table and slicked up his cock. Then his fingers pressed against Daniel’s hole, stretching and preparing.
“Relax, little guy. I’ll go slow. At first.”
Daniel bit his lip as Hayes’s fingers worked him open. The stretch was uncomfortable, then pleasurable. His tiny cock leaked onto Hayes’s stomach.
“Ready?”
Daniel nodded.
Hayes positioned his cock and pushed forward. The head breached Daniel’s entrance, and Daniel gasped at the intrusion. It was overwhelming—thick, hot, impossibly large.
“Breathe,” Hayes murmured, rubbing Daniel’s thigh. “You can take it. Little guys like you are made to take real men’s cocks.”
Daniel forced himself to relax, and Hayes slid deeper. Inch by inch, his massive cock filled Daniel’s ass, stretching him wider than he’d ever been stretched.
When Hayes was finally fully seated, his heavy balls resting against Daniel’s ass, Daniel felt impossibly full. His tiny cock throbbed, leaking steadily.
“Fuck,” Hayes groaned. “So tight. Like a vice.”
He began to move, slow thrusts that made Daniel moan with each stroke. The friction against his prostate was intense, sending waves of pleasure through his body.
“Look at that little cock,” Hayes said, staring down at Daniel’s two-inch erection bouncing with each thrust. “Pathetic. Can’t even reach my stomach. Useless little thing.”
Daniel whimpered, his hands bracing against Hayes’s broad shoulders.
“Say it,” Hayes commanded. “Say your cock is useless.”
“My cock is useless,” Daniel whispered.
“Louder.”
“My cock is useless! It’s tiny! It’s pathetic!”
Hayes fucked him harder, his massive cock slamming into Daniel’s prostate with each thrust. Daniel’s tiny cock spurted precum, his balls drawing up tight.
“Gonna cum,” Hayes grunted. “Gonna fill your ass with a real man’s load.”
He buried himself deep and groaned, his cock pulsing as he shot rope after rope of hot cum into Daniel’s ass. The sensation pushed Daniel over the edge—his tiny cock twitched as it released a few small spurts onto Hayes’s stomach.
They stayed tangled together, catching their breath. Hayes’s softening cock was still buried in Daniel’s ass, still impossibly large.
“Same time next week?” Hayes murmured against Daniel’s neck.
Daniel’s tiny cock twitched.
“Yes,” he breathed. “Every week.”
Hayes smiled and reached for the camera.
“Good little guy. Now let’s get a picture of my cum dripping out of your ass. Really document the difference between us.”
Daniel spread his legs wider, shame and arousal flooding through him in equal measure.
He’d found his place.
—
Daniel posed for the final photos—legs spread, Hayes’s cum leaking from his stretched hole, his tiny cock soft and barely visible between his thighs. Hayes snapped picture after picture, his massive cock swinging heavily as he moved around the room.
“Beautiful,” Hayes murmured, reviewing the shots on the camera display. “These are going in my special collection.”
Daniel’s face burned, but he didn’t move to cover himself. The shame had transformed into something else—a strange, warm acceptance. He belonged here. On his knees. Beneath a real man.
“Get dressed,” Hayes said, tossing Daniel’s clothes at him. “Same time next Friday. I’ll text you the details.”
Daniel pulled on his underwear, watching Hayes stroll naked to the kitchen. Even from across the room, the size difference was striking. Hayes’s soft cock swung past his mid-thigh with each step, his heavy balls bouncing slightly. Daniel’s own underwear bulged with nothing—just smooth fabric against his tiny nub.
—
One Week Later
Daniel stood outside Hayes’s apartment door, his heart pounding. He’d thought about nothing else all week. His tiny cock had been hard more often than not, leaking into his underwear at work, on the subway, in the shower. He’d measured himself again—still two inches. Still pathetic.
The door swung open.
Hayes stood there in loose boxer briefs, his massive cock outlined clearly against the thin fabric. The head peeked out from the leg opening, thick and dark.
“Right on time, little guy.” Hayes stepped aside. “I have a surprise for you tonight.”
Daniel entered, his eyes immediately drawn to the living room. Another man sat on the couch—broad-shouldered, bearded, with his legs spread wide. He wore only a jockstrap, and his cock was enormous. Not quite as long as Hayes’s, but thicker, with a prominent vein running along the shaft.
“This is Brock,” Hayes said, closing the door. “An old friend. I showed him your pictures, and he had to meet you.”
Brock stood and walked toward Daniel. His cock swung heavily with each step. “Tiny little thing, aren’t you?” He reached out and cupped Daniel’s crotch through his pants, feeling for himself. “Jesus. Is that it? That’s barely a clit.”
Daniel’s knees buckled slightly. Two massive cocks in one room. Two real men. And him—the joke between them.
“Strip,” Hayes commanded. “Let Brock see what you’re working with. Or not working with.”
Daniel removed his clothes slowly, his hands trembling. When he was fully naked, both men circled him, inspecting him like merchandise.
“Two inches hard, Brock,” Hayes said, stroking himself through his boxer briefs. “Maybe two and a half on a good day.”
Brock laughed, his thick cock jutting out from his body. “My head is bigger than his whole dick.”
“Get on your knees,” Hayes ordered. “Both of us are going to use that mouth tonight.”
Daniel sank to the floor. Hayes and Brock stood on either side of him, their massive cocks at eye level. Hayes pulled off his underwear, revealing his eleven-inch erection. Brock stepped out of his jockstrap, his thick eight-inch cock bobbing in front of Daniel’s face.
“Choose,” Hayes said. “Which one first?”
Daniel’s mouth watered. He turned to Hayes’s massive cock—the cock that had taken his virginity, filled him completely, made him understand his place. He leaned forward and licked a stripe up the long, veiny shaft.
“Good little guy,” Hayes murmured, threading his fingers through Daniel’s hair.
Daniel worked Hayes’s cock with his mouth, sucking the head while his hand stroked what he couldn’t fit. Brock’s thick cock pressed against his cheek, smearing precum across his skin.
“Switch,” Brock growled.
Daniel turned and took Brock’s thick cock into his mouth. The girth stretched his jaw wide, his lips straining to accommodate the thickness. He bobbed his head, tasting Brock’s salty precum.
“Fuck, he’s eager,” Brock groaned. “Where’d you find this little slut?”
“Police station,” Hayes said, stroking himself slowly. “Long story. But he knows his place now. Don’t you, little guy?”
Daniel pulled off Brock’s cock just long enough to answer. “Yes. I know my place.”
“Which is?”
“Below real men. Serving real cocks.”
Hayes and Brock exchanged satisfied grins.
“Get on the couch,” Hayes ordered. “On your hands and knees. Brock’s going to take that tight ass while you suck me.”
Daniel positioned himself, his tiny cock hanging between his legs—barely visible, a pathetic nub. Brock moved behind him, his thick cock pressing against Daniel’s already-lubed entrance.
“Hope you stretched like I told you,” Hayes said, kneeling on the couch in front of Daniel’s face.
Daniel had. Every day that week, he’d worn the plug Hayes gave him, preparing himself for this moment.
Brock pushed inside, his thick cock stretching Daniel wider than ever before. The girth was overwhelming, pressing against Daniel’s prostate with brutal intensity.
“Fuck, he’s tight,” Brock groaned, gripping Daniel’s hips. “Tighter than any pussy I’ve had.”
Daniel moaned around Hayes’s cock as Brock began to fuck him. The dual sensation—Brock’s thick cock pounding his ass, Hayes’s massive cock filling his throat—was overwhelming. His tiny cock swung uselessly between his legs, leaking onto the couch cushion.
“Look at that little thing,” Hayes said, reaching down to flick Daniel’s micropenis. “Pathetic. Can’t even call that a cock. Just a little clitty.”
Daniel whimpered, his hole clenching around Brock’s cock.
“He likes that,” Brock observed, fucking harder. “Likes being humiliated. Likes knowing he’ll never measure up.”
“Because he won’t,” Hayes agreed. “Ever. He’ll always be the little guy. The joke. The one who can’t satisfy anyone with that tiny nub.”
Daniel’s cock twitched, and he came—just a few small spurts onto the couch, untouched. His orgasm made his ass clench rhythmically around Brock’s cock.
“Already?” Brock laughed. “Little guy can’t even last. Pathetic.”
But they didn’t stop. They kept using him—Brock’s thick cock slamming into his prostate, Hayes’s massive cock hitting the back of his throat. Daniel existed only as a vessel for their pleasure, his own tiny cock soft and spent between his legs.
Brock came first, burying himself deep and flooding Daniel’s ass with cum. The warmth filled him, leaking out around Brock’s thick shaft.
Hayes pulled out of Daniel’s mouth and stroked himself rapidly. “Open wide, little guy.”
Daniel looked up just as Hayes’s cock erupted. Rope after rope of hot cum splashed across Daniel’s face—his cheeks, his nose, his lips, his forehead. He kept his eyes closed and his mouth open, accepting every drop.
When Hayes finished, Daniel was covered. Cum dripped from his chin onto his chest. His ass leaked Brock’s load. His tiny cock hung soft and small between his legs.
“Beautiful,” Hayes breathed, grabbing his phone. “Hold that position.”
Daniel stayed still while Hayes took picture after picture. Brock watched from the armchair, his softening cock still impressively thick against his thigh.
“Same time next week?” Brock asked, standing to retrieve his clothes. “I’ve got a buddy who’d love to meet this little slut.”
Hayes grinned. “The more, the better. Our little guy needs constant reminders of his place.”
Daniel looked up at them both—two massive, confident men with cocks that dwarfed his tiny nub. He felt a profound sense of belonging. This was where he was meant to be. On his knees. Covered in cum. Serving real men.
“Thank you,” he whispered.
Hayes cupped Daniel’s chin, smearing the cum across his skin. “You’re welcome, little guy. Now clean yourself up. I’ll text you the schedule for next week.”
—
One Month Later
Daniel knelt in Hayes’s living room, surrounded by five men—Hayes, Brock, and three new friends they’d invited. All of them were naked, all of them massively hung. Daniel’s tiny cock strained at its full two inches, overwhelmed by the display of masculinity around him.
“Ready for your birthday present, little guy?” Hayes asked.
Daniel nodded eagerly. He’d never felt more alive, more fulfilled, more certain of his purpose.
The men closed in around him, their massive cocks bobbing, their heavy balls swinging. Daniel opened his mouth and accepted his place in the world—beneath real men, serving real cocks, forever the little guy.
He wouldn’t have it any other way.
THE END.
*The opinions/views expressed in this story (and in any comments) are those of the author and do not represent this site. We support freedom of speech. This story has been submitted directly to this website for publication. Thanks for your submission.